rewrite → retrieve → answer → verify; every step is a mocked LLM sampling from logits via the Gumbel-max trick. Fixes are stronger models / a reranker / a grounding check.
Per-case drill-downq000 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 0' | 'synthetic question 0' |
| difficulty | 0.637 | 0.637 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q001 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 15; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 1' | 'synthetic question 1' |
| difficulty | 0.27 | 0.27 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q004 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 4' | 'synthetic question 4' |
| difficulty | 0.813 | 0.813 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q005 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.667 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 5' | 'synthetic question 5' |
| difficulty | 0.913 | 0.913 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q006 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 24; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 6' | 'synthetic question 6' |
| difficulty | 0.607 | 0.607 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q007 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 7' | 'synthetic question 7' |
| difficulty | 0.729 | 0.729 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q008 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 38; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 8' | 'synthetic question 8' |
| difficulty | 0.544 | 0.544 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q009 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 29; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 9' | 'synthetic question 9' |
| difficulty | 0.935 | 0.935 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q010 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 10' | 'synthetic question 10' |
| difficulty | 0.816 | 0.816 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q011 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 21; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 11' | 'synthetic question 11' |
| difficulty | 0.003 | 0.003 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'stale' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'stale_fact' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
q012 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 52; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 12' | 'synthetic question 12' |
| difficulty | 0.857 | 0.857 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q013 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 29; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 13' | 'synthetic question 13' |
| difficulty | 0.034 | 0.034 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q014 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 14' | 'synthetic question 14' |
| difficulty | 0.73 | 0.73 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q015 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| verify | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 24; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 15' | 'synthetic question 15' |
| difficulty | 0.176 | 0.176 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q016 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 16' | 'synthetic question 16' |
| difficulty | 0.863 | 0.863 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q017 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| verify | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 17' | 'synthetic question 17' |
| difficulty | 0.541 | 0.541 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q018 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 18' | 'synthetic question 18' |
| difficulty | 0.3 | 0.3 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q019 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 19' | 'synthetic question 19' |
| difficulty | 0.423 | 0.423 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q022 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 22' | 'synthetic question 22' |
| difficulty | 0.671 | 0.671 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q023 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 49; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 23' | 'synthetic question 23' |
| difficulty | 0.647 | 0.647 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q025 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 25' | 'synthetic question 25' |
| difficulty | 0.384 | 0.384 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q026 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 26' | 'synthetic question 26' |
| difficulty | 0.997 | 0.997 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q027 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 27' | 'synthetic question 27' |
| difficulty | 0.981 | 0.981 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'stale_fact' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q029 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 29' | 'synthetic question 29' |
| difficulty | 0.65 | 0.65 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q030 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.667 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 38; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 30' | 'synthetic question 30' |
| difficulty | 0.688 | 0.688 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q031 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 31' | 'synthetic question 31' |
| difficulty | 0.389 | 0.389 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q032 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 32' | 'synthetic question 32' |
| difficulty | 0.135 | 0.135 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q033 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.667 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 29; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 33' | 'synthetic question 33' |
| difficulty | 0.721 | 0.721 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q034 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.667 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 38; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 34' | 'synthetic question 34' |
| difficulty | 0.525 | 0.525 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q036 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 36' | 'synthetic question 36' |
| difficulty | 0.486 | 0.486 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q037 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 37' | 'synthetic question 37' |
| difficulty | 0.889 | 0.889 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q038 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 38; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 38' | 'synthetic question 38' |
| difficulty | 0.934 | 0.934 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q039 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 26; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 39' | 'synthetic question 39' |
| difficulty | 0.358 | 0.358 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q040 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 40' | 'synthetic question 40' |
| difficulty | 0.572 | 0.572 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'stale' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
q041 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 41' | 'synthetic question 41' |
| difficulty | 0.322 | 0.322 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q042 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 46; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 42' | 'synthetic question 42' |
| difficulty | 0.594 | 0.594 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q043 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 43' | 'synthetic question 43' |
| difficulty | 0.338 | 0.338 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q044 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.250 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.250 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.250 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.250 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 38; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 44' | 'synthetic question 44' |
| difficulty | 0.392 | 0.392 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q045 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 24; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 45' | 'synthetic question 45' |
| difficulty | 0.89 | 0.89 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q046 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 46' | 'synthetic question 46' |
| difficulty | 0.227 | 0.227 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q047 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 26; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 47' | 'synthetic question 47' |
| difficulty | 0.623 | 0.623 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q048 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 48' | 'synthetic question 48' |
| difficulty | 0.084 | 0.084 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q050 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.667 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 50' | 'synthetic question 50' |
| difficulty | 0.787 | 0.787 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q052 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 21; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 52' | 'synthetic question 52' |
| difficulty | 0.876 | 0.876 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'stale_fact' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
q053 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 29; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 53' | 'synthetic question 53' |
| difficulty | 0.059 | 0.059 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q054 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 54' | 'synthetic question 54' |
| difficulty | 0.336 | 0.336 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q055 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 52; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 55' | 'synthetic question 55' |
| difficulty | 0.15 | 0.15 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q056 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 56' | 'synthetic question 56' |
| difficulty | 0.45 | 0.45 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q057 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 57; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 57' | 'synthetic question 57' |
| difficulty | 0.796 | 0.796 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q058 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 43; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 58' | 'synthetic question 58' |
| difficulty | 0.231 | 0.231 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q059 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 59' | 'synthetic question 59' |
| difficulty | 0.052 | 0.052 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q060 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 60' | 'synthetic question 60' |
| difficulty | 0.405 | 0.405 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q061 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 61' | 'synthetic question 61' |
| difficulty | 0.199 | 0.199 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q062 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 62' | 'synthetic question 62' |
| difficulty | 0.091 | 0.091 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q063 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 46; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 63' | 'synthetic question 63' |
| difficulty | 0.58 | 0.58 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q064 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 43; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 64' | 'synthetic question 64' |
| difficulty | 0.299 | 0.299 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q066 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 66' | 'synthetic question 66' |
| difficulty | 0.2 | 0.2 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q067 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 49; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 67' | 'synthetic question 67' |
| difficulty | 0.942 | 0.942 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q068 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 29; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 68' | 'synthetic question 68' |
| difficulty | 0.365 | 0.365 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q069 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 69' | 'synthetic question 69' |
| difficulty | 0.105 | 0.105 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q070 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 70' | 'synthetic question 70' |
| difficulty | 0.629 | 0.629 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q071 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 43; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 71' | 'synthetic question 71' |
| difficulty | 0.927 | 0.927 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q072 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.333 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.333 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.333 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 72' | 'synthetic question 72' |
| difficulty | 0.44 | 0.44 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q073 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 46; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 73' | 'synthetic question 73' |
| difficulty | 0.955 | 0.955 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q074 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 46; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 74' | 'synthetic question 74' |
| difficulty | 0.5 | 0.5 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q075 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.667 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 46; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 75' | 'synthetic question 75' |
| difficulty | 0.425 | 0.425 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q077 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 29; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 77' | 'synthetic question 77' |
| difficulty | 0.995 | 0.995 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q078 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.250 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.250 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.250 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.250 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 78' | 'synthetic question 78' |
| difficulty | 0.949 | 0.949 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q079 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 79' | 'synthetic question 79' |
| difficulty | 0.46 | 0.46 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q083 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 46; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 83' | 'synthetic question 83' |
| difficulty | 0.786 | 0.786 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q086 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 86' | 'synthetic question 86' |
| difficulty | 0.711 | 0.711 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q089 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.667 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 89' | 'synthetic question 89' |
| difficulty | 0.729 | 0.729 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q090 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| verify | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 24; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 90' | 'synthetic question 90' |
| difficulty | 0.927 | 0.927 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q091 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 91' | 'synthetic question 91' |
| difficulty | 0.968 | 0.968 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q093 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 93' | 'synthetic question 93' |
| difficulty | 0.864 | 0.864 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q094 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 38; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 94' | 'synthetic question 94' |
| difficulty | 0.981 | 0.981 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q095 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 38; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 95' | 'synthetic question 95' |
| difficulty | 0.957 | 0.957 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q096 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 29; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 96' | 'synthetic question 96' |
| difficulty | 0.149 | 0.149 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q098 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 98' | 'synthetic question 98' |
| difficulty | 0.89 | 0.89 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q099 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 99' | 'synthetic question 99' |
| difficulty | 0.822 | 0.822 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q100 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 29; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 100' | 'synthetic question 100' |
| difficulty | 0.48 | 0.48 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q101 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 101' | 'synthetic question 101' |
| difficulty | 0.232 | 0.232 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q102 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 29; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 102' | 'synthetic question 102' |
| difficulty | 0.802 | 0.802 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q103 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 103' | 'synthetic question 103' |
| difficulty | 0.924 | 0.924 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q104 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.667 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 29; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 104' | 'synthetic question 104' |
| difficulty | 0.266 | 0.266 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q105 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| verify | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 24; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 105' | 'synthetic question 105' |
| difficulty | 0.539 | 0.539 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q107 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 107' | 'synthetic question 107' |
| difficulty | 0.931 | 0.931 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q108 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 108' | 'synthetic question 108' |
| difficulty | 0.041 | 0.041 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q109 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 109' | 'synthetic question 109' |
| difficulty | 0.732 | 0.732 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q110 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 110' | 'synthetic question 110' |
| difficulty | 0.614 | 0.614 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q111 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.667 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 111' | 'synthetic question 111' |
| difficulty | 0.028 | 0.028 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q113 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.667 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 113' | 'synthetic question 113' |
| difficulty | 0.016 | 0.016 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q115 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 115' | 'synthetic question 115' |
| difficulty | 0.513 | 0.513 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q116 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 15; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 116' | 'synthetic question 116' |
| difficulty | 0.929 | 0.929 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'stale_fact' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
q117 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 117' | 'synthetic question 117' |
| difficulty | 0.066 | 0.066 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q118 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.667 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 118' | 'synthetic question 118' |
| difficulty | 0.841 | 0.841 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q120 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 38; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 120' | 'synthetic question 120' |
| difficulty | 0.344 | 0.344 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q121 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 26; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 121' | 'synthetic question 121' |
| difficulty | 0.43 | 0.43 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q122 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.417 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 38; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 122' | 'synthetic question 122' |
| difficulty | 0.966 | 0.966 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q123 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 26; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 123' | 'synthetic question 123' |
| difficulty | 0.562 | 0.562 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q124 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 15; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 124' | 'synthetic question 124' |
| difficulty | 0.259 | 0.259 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'stale' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'stale_fact' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
q126 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 29; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 126' | 'synthetic question 126' |
| difficulty | 0.888 | 0.888 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q127 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 127' | 'synthetic question 127' |
| difficulty | 0.226 | 0.226 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q128 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 128' | 'synthetic question 128' |
| difficulty | 0.125 | 0.125 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q129 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 129' | 'synthetic question 129' |
| difficulty | 0.288 | 0.288 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q130 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 130' | 'synthetic question 130' |
| difficulty | 0.586 | 0.586 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q131 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 131' | 'synthetic question 131' |
| difficulty | 0.554 | 0.554 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q132 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 132' | 'synthetic question 132' |
| difficulty | 0.81 | 0.81 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'stale' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
q133 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 49; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 133' | 'synthetic question 133' |
| difficulty | 0.56 | 0.56 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q135 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| verify | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 135' | 'synthetic question 135' |
| difficulty | 0.413 | 0.413 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q136 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 136' | 'synthetic question 136' |
| difficulty | 0.818 | 0.818 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q137 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 137' | 'synthetic question 137' |
| difficulty | 0.627 | 0.627 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q140 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 15; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 140' | 'synthetic question 140' |
| difficulty | 0.553 | 0.553 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'irrelevant' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q142 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.667 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 29; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 142' | 'synthetic question 142' |
| difficulty | 0.848 | 0.848 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q143 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 29; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 143' | 'synthetic question 143' |
| difficulty | 0.145 | 0.145 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
q145 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| verify | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 145' | 'synthetic question 145' |
| difficulty | 0.91 | 0.91 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q146 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 146' | 'synthetic question 146' |
| difficulty | 0.043 | 0.043 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q148 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 148' | 'synthetic question 148' |
| difficulty | 0.415 | 0.415 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q150 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 150' | 'synthetic question 150' |
| difficulty | 0.01 | 0.01 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q151 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 151' | 'synthetic question 151' |
| difficulty | 0.365 | 0.365 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q153 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| verify | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 153' | 'synthetic question 153' |
| difficulty | 0.653 | 0.653 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q155 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.667 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 38; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 155' | 'synthetic question 155' |
| difficulty | 0.703 | 0.703 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q156 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 156' | 'synthetic question 156' |
| difficulty | 0.944 | 0.944 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q158 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 26; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 158' | 'synthetic question 158' |
| difficulty | 0.865 | 0.865 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q159 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 159' | 'synthetic question 159' |
| difficulty | 0.059 | 0.059 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q162 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.333 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.333 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.333 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 162' | 'synthetic question 162' |
| difficulty | 0.489 | 0.489 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q163 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 163' | 'synthetic question 163' |
| difficulty | 0.976 | 0.976 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q165 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.667 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 38; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 165' | 'synthetic question 165' |
| difficulty | 0.309 | 0.309 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q166 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 166' | 'synthetic question 166' |
| difficulty | 0.27 | 0.27 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q167 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.667 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 38; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 167' | 'synthetic question 167' |
| difficulty | 0.863 | 0.863 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q169 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 15; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 169' | 'synthetic question 169' |
| difficulty | 0.511 | 0.511 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'irrelevant' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q170 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 170' | 'synthetic question 170' |
| difficulty | 0.344 | 0.344 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q171 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| verify | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 24; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 171' | 'synthetic question 171' |
| difficulty | 0.995 | 0.995 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q172 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 172' | 'synthetic question 172' |
| difficulty | 0.316 | 0.316 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q173 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 24; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 173' | 'synthetic question 173' |
| difficulty | 0.183 | 0.183 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q174 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 174' | 'synthetic question 174' |
| difficulty | 0.88 | 0.88 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'irrelevant' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q175 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 29; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 175' | 'synthetic question 175' |
| difficulty | 0.812 | 0.812 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q176 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 176' | 'synthetic question 176' |
| difficulty | 0.668 | 0.668 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q177 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 38; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 177' | 'synthetic question 177' |
| difficulty | 0.958 | 0.958 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q178 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.667 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 29; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 178' | 'synthetic question 178' |
| difficulty | 0.926 | 0.926 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q179 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 179' | 'synthetic question 179' |
| difficulty | 0.748 | 0.748 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q181 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 29; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 181' | 'synthetic question 181' |
| difficulty | 0.247 | 0.247 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q182 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 182' | 'synthetic question 182' |
| difficulty | 0.141 | 0.141 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q183 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 46; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 183' | 'synthetic question 183' |
| difficulty | 0.67 | 0.67 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q184 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.667 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 29; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 184' | 'synthetic question 184' |
| difficulty | 0.715 | 0.715 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q185 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 185' | 'synthetic question 185' |
| difficulty | 0.167 | 0.167 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q187 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 187' | 'synthetic question 187' |
| difficulty | 0.91 | 0.91 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q188 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.333 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.333 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.333 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 35; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 188' | 'synthetic question 188' |
| difficulty | 0.561 | 0.561 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q191 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 18; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 191' | 'synthetic question 191' |
| difficulty | 0.526 | 0.526 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q192 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 32; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 192' | 'synthetic question 192' |
| difficulty | 0.523 | 0.523 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
… 4 more cases omitted.
Per-case drill-downq000 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.146 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.625 | +0.417 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.146 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.167 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 313; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 0' | 'synthetic question 0' |
| difficulty | 0.637 | 0.637 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q001 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.750 | +0.562 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.375 | +0.188 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 254; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 1' | 'synthetic question 1' |
| difficulty | 0.27 | 0.27 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q004 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.625 | +0.344 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.625 | +0.281 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.094 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.156 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 325; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 4' | 'synthetic question 4' |
| difficulty | 0.813 | 0.813 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q005 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.271 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.271 | | |
| answer | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.292 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 291; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 5' | 'synthetic question 5' |
| difficulty | 0.913 | 0.913 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q006 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.292 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.354 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.229 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 325; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 6' | 'synthetic question 6' |
| difficulty | 0.607 | 0.607 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q007 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.875 | +0.458 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.625 | +0.271 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.042 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.104 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 308; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 7' | 'synthetic question 7' |
| difficulty | 0.729 | 0.729 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q008 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.365 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.250 | +0.427 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.135 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.073 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 339; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 8' | 'synthetic question 8' |
| difficulty | 0.544 | 0.544 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q009 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.25, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.188 | | ◆ |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 215; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 9' | 'synthetic question 9' |
| difficulty | 0.935 | 0.935 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q010 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.625 | +0.312 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.500 | +0.250 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.146 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 300; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 10' | 'synthetic question 10' |
| difficulty | 0.816 | 0.816 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q011 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.375 | +0.375 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.250 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 294; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 11' | 'synthetic question 11' |
| difficulty | 0.003 | 0.003 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q012 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.625 | +0.531 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.198 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.115 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 359; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 12' | 'synthetic question 12' |
| difficulty | 0.857 | 0.857 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q013 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +1.000 | +1.000 | +1.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 262; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 13' | 'synthetic question 13' |
| difficulty | 0.034 | 0.034 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q014 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.271 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.271 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.375 | +0.208 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 296; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 14' | 'synthetic question 14' |
| difficulty | 0.73 | 0.73 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q015 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | |
| verify | +1.000 | +0.000 | +0.500 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 222; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 15' | 'synthetic question 15' |
| difficulty | 0.176 | 0.176 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q016 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.167 | | |
| retrieve | +0.625 | +0.625 | +0.625 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 287; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 16' | 'synthetic question 16' |
| difficulty | 0.863 | 0.863 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q017 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: verify
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.500 | +0.000 | +0.250 | | |
| verify | +0.750 | +0.250 | +0.500 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 180; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 17' | 'synthetic question 17' |
| difficulty | 0.541 | 0.541 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'stale_fact' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
q018 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.271 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.333 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.146 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 287; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 18' | 'synthetic question 18' |
| difficulty | 0.3 | 0.3 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q019 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.219 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.625 | +0.531 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.094 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 304; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 19' | 'synthetic question 19' |
| difficulty | 0.423 | 0.423 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q022 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.50, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.188 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.188 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.125 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 248; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 22' | 'synthetic question 22' |
| difficulty | 0.671 | 0.671 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q023 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.625 | +0.469 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.281 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.094 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.156 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 347; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 23' | 'synthetic question 23' |
| difficulty | 0.647 | 0.647 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'stale_fact' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q025 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.750 | +0.625 | +0.667 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.229 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.104 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 321; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 25' | 'synthetic question 25' |
| difficulty | 0.384 | 0.384 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q026 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.750 | +0.625 | +0.688 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.188 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 331; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 26' | 'synthetic question 26' |
| difficulty | 0.997 | 0.997 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q027 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.62, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.219 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.281 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.094 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 259; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 27' | 'synthetic question 27' |
| difficulty | 0.981 | 0.981 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q029 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.146 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.208 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.625 | +0.396 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 279; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 29' | 'synthetic question 29' |
| difficulty | 0.65 | 0.65 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q030 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.750 | +0.542 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.271 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 381; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 30' | 'synthetic question 30' |
| difficulty | 0.688 | 0.688 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q031 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.750 | +0.542 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.375 | +0.229 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 316; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 31' | 'synthetic question 31' |
| difficulty | 0.389 | 0.389 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q032 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.750 | +0.479 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.625 | +0.354 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.042 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 290; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 32' | 'synthetic question 32' |
| difficulty | 0.135 | 0.135 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q033 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.198 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.323 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.219 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.010 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 274; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 33' | 'synthetic question 33' |
| difficulty | 0.721 | 0.721 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q034 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.625 | +0.604 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.146 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.188 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 359; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 34' | 'synthetic question 34' |
| difficulty | 0.525 | 0.525 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q036 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.271 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.500 | +0.354 | | |
| answer | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.292 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 308; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 36' | 'synthetic question 36' |
| difficulty | 0.486 | 0.486 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q037 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.229 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.292 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.500 | +0.229 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 310; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 37' | 'synthetic question 37' |
| difficulty | 0.889 | 0.889 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q038 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +1.000 | +0.500 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.500 | +0.229 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.104 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.167 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 381; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 38' | 'synthetic question 38' |
| difficulty | 0.934 | 0.934 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q039 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.62, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.625 | +0.625 | +0.625 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 234; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 39' | 'synthetic question 39' |
| difficulty | 0.358 | 0.358 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q040 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.312 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.250 | +0.438 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 299; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 40' | 'synthetic question 40' |
| difficulty | 0.572 | 0.572 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q041 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.302 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.302 | | |
| answer | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.260 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.010 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 297; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 41' | 'synthetic question 41' |
| difficulty | 0.322 | 0.322 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q042 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.750 | +0.583 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 336; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 42' | 'synthetic question 42' |
| difficulty | 0.594 | 0.594 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q043 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.500 | +0.250 | +0.323 | | |
| retrieve | +0.625 | +0.500 | +0.531 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.115 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 313; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 43' | 'synthetic question 43' |
| difficulty | 0.338 | 0.338 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q044 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.208 | | |
| retrieve | +0.625 | +0.750 | +0.729 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 332; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 44' | 'synthetic question 44' |
| difficulty | 0.392 | 0.392 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q045 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.750 | +0.375 | +0.562 | | |
| verify | +0.625 | +0.250 | +0.437 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 216; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 45' | 'synthetic question 45' |
| difficulty | 0.89 | 0.89 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q046 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.208 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.625 | +0.521 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.104 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 322; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 46' | 'synthetic question 46' |
| difficulty | 0.227 | 0.227 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q047 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.208 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.271 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.500 | +0.271 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 276; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 47' | 'synthetic question 47' |
| difficulty | 0.623 | 0.623 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q048 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.38, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.271 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 308; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 48' | 'synthetic question 48' |
| difficulty | 0.084 | 0.084 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'irrelevant' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q050 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.625 | +0.500 | +0.542 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.229 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.042 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 338; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 50' | 'synthetic question 50' |
| difficulty | 0.787 | 0.787 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q052 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.625 | +0.375 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.375 | +0.167 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.188 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 280; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 52' | 'synthetic question 52' |
| difficulty | 0.876 | 0.876 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q053 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.62, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.625 | +0.562 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 241; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 53' | 'synthetic question 53' |
| difficulty | 0.059 | 0.059 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q054 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.750 | +0.000 | +0.406 | | |
| retrieve | +0.875 | +0.125 | +0.531 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 301; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 54' | 'synthetic question 54' |
| difficulty | 0.336 | 0.336 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q055 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.625 | +0.292 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.625 | +0.292 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 307; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 55' | 'synthetic question 55' |
| difficulty | 0.15 | 0.15 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q056 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.625 | +0.500 | +0.542 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.229 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.104 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 318; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 56' | 'synthetic question 56' |
| difficulty | 0.45 | 0.45 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q057 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.750 | +0.604 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.271 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 350; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 57' | 'synthetic question 57' |
| difficulty | 0.796 | 0.796 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q058 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.625 | +0.417 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.167 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.375 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 310; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 58' | 'synthetic question 58' |
| difficulty | 0.231 | 0.231 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'wrong_entity' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'irrelevant' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q059 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.750 | +0.750 | +0.750 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 186; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 59' | 'synthetic question 59' |
| difficulty | 0.052 | 0.052 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q060 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +0.125 | +0.562 | | |
| verify | +0.875 | +0.000 | +0.437 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 192; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 60' | 'synthetic question 60' |
| difficulty | 0.405 | 0.405 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q061 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +0.375 | +0.688 | | |
| verify | +0.625 | +0.000 | +0.312 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 192; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 61' | 'synthetic question 61' |
| difficulty | 0.199 | 0.199 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q062 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.625 | +0.875 | +0.771 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.146 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 263; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 62' | 'synthetic question 62' |
| difficulty | 0.091 | 0.091 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q063 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.354 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.229 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 327; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 63' | 'synthetic question 63' |
| difficulty | 0.58 | 0.58 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'stale_fact' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q064 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.625 | +0.750 | +0.688 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.188 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.125 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 346; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 64' | 'synthetic question 64' |
| difficulty | 0.299 | 0.299 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q066 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.875 | +0.125 | +0.500 | | |
| verify | +0.875 | +0.125 | +0.500 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 189; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 66' | 'synthetic question 66' |
| difficulty | 0.2 | 0.2 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q067 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.875 | +0.667 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.188 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.104 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 347; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 67' | 'synthetic question 67' |
| difficulty | 0.942 | 0.942 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q068 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.750 | +0.625 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.187 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 255; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 68' | 'synthetic question 68' |
| difficulty | 0.365 | 0.365 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q069 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.500 | +0.281 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.625 | +0.406 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.260 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.052 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 317; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 69' | 'synthetic question 69' |
| difficulty | 0.105 | 0.105 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q070 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.500 | +0.750 | +0.667 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.146 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.146 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 364; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 70' | 'synthetic question 70' |
| difficulty | 0.629 | 0.629 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q071 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.333 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.333 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 322; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 71' | 'synthetic question 71' |
| difficulty | 0.927 | 0.927 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q072 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.750 | +0.365 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.625 | +0.281 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.073 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 309; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 72' | 'synthetic question 72' |
| difficulty | 0.44 | 0.44 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q073 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.62, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.625 | +0.365 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.375 | +0.177 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.010 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.073 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 324; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 73' | 'synthetic question 73' |
| difficulty | 0.955 | 0.955 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'wrong_entity' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q074 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.250 | | |
| retrieve | +0.750 | +0.500 | +0.625 | | ◆ |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 317; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 74' | 'synthetic question 74' |
| difficulty | 0.5 | 0.5 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q075 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.500 | +0.344 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.625 | +0.406 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.115 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.010 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 322; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 75' | 'synthetic question 75' |
| difficulty | 0.425 | 0.425 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q077 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.104 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.750 | +0.646 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.146 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.104 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 307; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 77' | 'synthetic question 77' |
| difficulty | 0.995 | 0.995 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q078 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.625 | +0.667 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.104 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.104 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 322; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 78' | 'synthetic question 78' |
| difficulty | 0.949 | 0.949 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q079 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.365 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.365 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.240 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 314; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 79' | 'synthetic question 79' |
| difficulty | 0.46 | 0.46 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q083 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.875 | +0.490 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.625 | +0.302 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.375 | +0.198 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.010 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 347; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 83' | 'synthetic question 83' |
| difficulty | 0.786 | 0.786 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q086 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.50, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.292 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.104 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.104 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 260; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 86' | 'synthetic question 86' |
| difficulty | 0.711 | 0.711 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q089 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.62, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.292 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.292 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.042 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 285; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 89' | 'synthetic question 89' |
| difficulty | 0.729 | 0.729 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q090 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.875 | +0.250 | +0.562 | | |
| verify | +0.750 | +0.125 | +0.438 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 237; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 90' | 'synthetic question 90' |
| difficulty | 0.927 | 0.927 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q091 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.500 | +0.385 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.625 | +0.448 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.073 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.094 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 333; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 91' | 'synthetic question 91' |
| difficulty | 0.968 | 0.968 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q093 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.62, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.250 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.104 | | |
| answer | +0.375 | +0.000 | +0.250 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 298; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 93' | 'synthetic question 93' |
| difficulty | 0.864 | 0.864 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q094 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.875 | +0.490 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.500 | +0.219 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.198 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.094 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 331; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 94' | 'synthetic question 94' |
| difficulty | 0.981 | 0.981 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q095 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.260 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.260 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.260 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.094 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 326; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 95' | 'synthetic question 95' |
| difficulty | 0.957 | 0.957 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q096 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.292 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.417 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.229 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 345; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 96' | 'synthetic question 96' |
| difficulty | 0.149 | 0.149 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q098 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.750 | +0.750 | +0.750 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 186; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 98' | 'synthetic question 98' |
| difficulty | 0.89 | 0.89 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q099 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.500 | +0.750 | +0.646 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 293; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 99' | 'synthetic question 99' |
| difficulty | 0.822 | 0.822 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q100 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.625 | +0.750 | +0.688 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 237; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 100' | 'synthetic question 100' |
| difficulty | 0.48 | 0.48 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q101 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.62, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.625 | +0.625 | +0.625 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 183; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 101' | 'synthetic question 101' |
| difficulty | 0.232 | 0.232 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q102 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.62, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.500 | +0.312 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.250 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 242; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 102' | 'synthetic question 102' |
| difficulty | 0.802 | 0.802 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q103 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.875 | +0.646 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 275; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 103' | 'synthetic question 103' |
| difficulty | 0.924 | 0.924 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q104 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.750 | +0.875 | +0.833 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 254; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 104' | 'synthetic question 104' |
| difficulty | 0.266 | 0.266 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q105 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.875 | +0.250 | +0.562 | | |
| verify | +0.750 | +0.125 | +0.438 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 225; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 105' | 'synthetic question 105' |
| difficulty | 0.539 | 0.539 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q107 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.875 | +0.750 | +0.812 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 332; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 107' | 'synthetic question 107' |
| difficulty | 0.931 | 0.931 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q108 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.500 | +0.750 | +0.635 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.156 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.115 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.094 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 381; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 108' | 'synthetic question 108' |
| difficulty | 0.041 | 0.041 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q109 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.875 | +0.875 | +0.875 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 189; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 109' | 'synthetic question 109' |
| difficulty | 0.732 | 0.732 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q110 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.292 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.292 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 322; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 110' | 'synthetic question 110' |
| difficulty | 0.614 | 0.614 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q111 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.500 | +0.875 | +0.708 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.146 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 350; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 111' | 'synthetic question 111' |
| difficulty | 0.028 | 0.028 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q113 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.500 | +0.250 | +0.396 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.250 | +0.396 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.208 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 328; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 113' | 'synthetic question 113' |
| difficulty | 0.016 | 0.016 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q115 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.625 | +0.333 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.625 | +0.333 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.146 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 317; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 115' | 'synthetic question 115' |
| difficulty | 0.513 | 0.513 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q116 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.625 | +0.312 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.625 | +0.312 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 311; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 116' | 'synthetic question 116' |
| difficulty | 0.929 | 0.929 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
q117 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.62, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.625 | +0.479 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.042 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.104 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 265; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 117' | 'synthetic question 117' |
| difficulty | 0.066 | 0.066 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'wrong_entity' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q118 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.281 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.375 | +0.406 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.156 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 302; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 118' | 'synthetic question 118' |
| difficulty | 0.841 | 0.841 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q120 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.500 | +0.250 | +0.365 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.250 | +0.365 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.115 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 333; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 120' | 'synthetic question 120' |
| difficulty | 0.344 | 0.344 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q121 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.62, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.625 | +0.375 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.500 | +0.250 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 246; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 121' | 'synthetic question 121' |
| difficulty | 0.43 | 0.43 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q122 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.500 | +0.250 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.625 | +0.312 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.104 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.375 | +0.208 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 293; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 122' | 'synthetic question 122' |
| difficulty | 0.966 | 0.966 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q123 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.62, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.625 | +0.438 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.375 | +0.188 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 232; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 123' | 'synthetic question 123' |
| difficulty | 0.562 | 0.562 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q124 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.750 | +1.000 | +0.917 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 271; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 124' | 'synthetic question 124' |
| difficulty | 0.259 | 0.259 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q126 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.750 | +0.646 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 252; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 126' | 'synthetic question 126' |
| difficulty | 0.888 | 0.888 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q127 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.281 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.375 | +0.469 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.240 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.010 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 307; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 127' | 'synthetic question 127' |
| difficulty | 0.226 | 0.226 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q128 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.625 | +0.427 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.625 | +0.427 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.135 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.010 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 331; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 128' | 'synthetic question 128' |
| difficulty | 0.125 | 0.125 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q129 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.875 | +0.594 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.156 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.094 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.156 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 327; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 129' | 'synthetic question 129' |
| difficulty | 0.288 | 0.288 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q130 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.500 | +0.250 | +0.385 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.250 | +0.385 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.073 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 343; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 130' | 'synthetic question 130' |
| difficulty | 0.586 | 0.586 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q131 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.323 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.323 | | |
| answer | +0.375 | +0.000 | +0.219 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.010 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 317; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 131' | 'synthetic question 131' |
| difficulty | 0.554 | 0.554 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q132 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.750 | +1.000 | +0.896 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 274; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 132' | 'synthetic question 132' |
| difficulty | 0.81 | 0.81 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q133 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.625 | +0.479 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.292 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 375; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 133' | 'synthetic question 133' |
| difficulty | 0.56 | 0.56 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q135 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.875 | +0.125 | +0.500 | | |
| verify | +0.875 | +0.125 | +0.500 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 189; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 135' | 'synthetic question 135' |
| difficulty | 0.413 | 0.413 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q136 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.750 | +0.490 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.260 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.094 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.156 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 384; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 136' | 'synthetic question 136' |
| difficulty | 0.818 | 0.818 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q137 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.219 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.385 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.198 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.073 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 313; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 137' | 'synthetic question 137' |
| difficulty | 0.627 | 0.627 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q140 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.229 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.500 | +0.479 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 312; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 140' | 'synthetic question 140' |
| difficulty | 0.553 | 0.553 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q142 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.62, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.625 | +0.562 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 237; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 142' | 'synthetic question 142' |
| difficulty | 0.848 | 0.848 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q143 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.875 | +0.729 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.104 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 277; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 143' | 'synthetic question 143' |
| difficulty | 0.145 | 0.145 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q145 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +0.250 | +0.625 | | |
| verify | +0.750 | +0.000 | +0.375 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 192; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 145' | 'synthetic question 145' |
| difficulty | 0.91 | 0.91 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q146 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.875 | +0.000 | +0.448 | | |
| retrieve | +0.875 | +0.000 | +0.448 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.073 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 328; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 146' | 'synthetic question 146' |
| difficulty | 0.043 | 0.043 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q148 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.62, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.250 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.250 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.104 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 286; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 148' | 'synthetic question 148' |
| difficulty | 0.415 | 0.415 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q150 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.625 | +0.500 | +0.583 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 308; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 150' | 'synthetic question 150' |
| difficulty | 0.01 | 0.01 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'wrong_entity' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'irrelevant' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q151 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.146 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.625 | +0.604 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.104 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 310; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 151' | 'synthetic question 151' |
| difficulty | 0.365 | 0.365 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q153 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +0.250 | +0.625 | | |
| verify | +0.750 | +0.000 | +0.375 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 222; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 153' | 'synthetic question 153' |
| difficulty | 0.653 | 0.653 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q155 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.875 | +0.625 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.042 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.375 | +0.188 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 350; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 155' | 'synthetic question 155' |
| difficulty | 0.703 | 0.703 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q156 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.156 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.302 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.219 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.073 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 302; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 156' | 'synthetic question 156' |
| difficulty | 0.944 | 0.944 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q158 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.750 | +0.875 | +0.854 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.104 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 274; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 158' | 'synthetic question 158' |
| difficulty | 0.865 | 0.865 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q159 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.271 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.250 | +0.333 | | |
| answer | +0.625 | +0.125 | +0.375 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 328; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 159' | 'synthetic question 159' |
| difficulty | 0.059 | 0.059 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q162 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.500 | +0.250 | +0.375 | | |
| retrieve | +0.625 | +0.375 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 302; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 162' | 'synthetic question 162' |
| difficulty | 0.489 | 0.489 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q163 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.625 | +0.750 | +0.667 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.167 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.042 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 365; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 163' | 'synthetic question 163' |
| difficulty | 0.976 | 0.976 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q165 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.500 | +0.750 | +0.677 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.094 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.052 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.052 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 325; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 165' | 'synthetic question 165' |
| difficulty | 0.309 | 0.309 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q166 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.62, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.271 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.271 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 283; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 166' | 'synthetic question 166' |
| difficulty | 0.27 | 0.27 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q167 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.625 | +0.573 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.156 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.052 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.219 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 384; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 167' | 'synthetic question 167' |
| difficulty | 0.863 | 0.863 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q169 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.625 | +1.000 | +0.812 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.375 | +0.188 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 265; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 169' | 'synthetic question 169' |
| difficulty | 0.511 | 0.511 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q170 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.875 | +0.625 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 263; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 170' | 'synthetic question 170' |
| difficulty | 0.344 | 0.344 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q171 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +1.000 | +0.250 | +0.625 | | |
| verify | +0.750 | +0.000 | +0.375 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 234; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 171' | 'synthetic question 171' |
| difficulty | 0.995 | 0.995 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q172 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.750 | +0.500 | | ◆ |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.312 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 296; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 172' | 'synthetic question 172' |
| difficulty | 0.316 | 0.316 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q173 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.750 | +0.750 | +0.750 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 234; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 173' | 'synthetic question 173' |
| difficulty | 0.183 | 0.183 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q174 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.875 | +0.646 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.146 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 283; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 174' | 'synthetic question 174' |
| difficulty | 0.88 | 0.88 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q175 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.62, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.125 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.312 | | ◆ |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.375 | +0.188 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 306; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 175' | 'synthetic question 175' |
| difficulty | 0.812 | 0.812 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q176 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.750 | +0.396 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.625 | +0.312 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 347; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 176' | 'synthetic question 176' |
| difficulty | 0.668 | 0.668 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q177 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.750 | +0.531 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.156 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.094 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.094 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 395; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 177' | 'synthetic question 177' |
| difficulty | 0.958 | 0.958 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q178 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.156 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.625 | +0.365 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.115 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.115 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 279; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 178' | 'synthetic question 178' |
| difficulty | 0.926 | 0.926 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q179 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.271 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.375 | +0.396 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 302; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 179' | 'synthetic question 179' |
| difficulty | 0.748 | 0.748 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'stale' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
q181 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.625 | +0.625 | +0.625 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 235; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 181' | 'synthetic question 181' |
| difficulty | 0.247 | 0.247 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q182 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.750 | +0.750 | +0.750 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 186; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 182' | 'synthetic question 182' |
| difficulty | 0.141 | 0.141 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q183 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.625 | +0.396 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.625 | +0.333 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.146 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 321; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 183' | 'synthetic question 183' |
| difficulty | 0.67 | 0.67 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q184 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.385 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.385 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.156 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.073 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 331; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 184' | 'synthetic question 184' |
| difficulty | 0.715 | 0.715 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q185 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.625 | +0.750 | +0.688 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.312 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 332; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 185' | 'synthetic question 185' |
| difficulty | 0.167 | 0.167 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q187 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.750 | +0.458 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.375 | +0.229 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.146 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 389; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 187' | 'synthetic question 187' |
| difficulty | 0.91 | 0.91 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q188 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.750 | +0.583 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.104 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.208 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.104 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 395; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 188' | 'synthetic question 188' |
| difficulty | 0.561 | 0.561 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q191 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.62, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.625 | +0.625 | +0.625 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 183; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 191' | 'synthetic question 191' |
| difficulty | 0.526 | 0.526 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q192 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.146 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.500 | +0.458 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.500 | +0.271 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 298; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 192' | 'synthetic question 192' |
| difficulty | 0.523 | 0.523 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
… 4 more cases omitted.
Per-case drill-downq000 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.625 | +0.396 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.208 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.292 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.104 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 322; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 0' | 'synthetic question 0' |
| difficulty | 0.637 | 0.637 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q001 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.375 | +0.396 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.146 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 250; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 1' | 'synthetic question 1' |
| difficulty | 0.27 | 0.27 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q004 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.271 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.500 | +0.458 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.104 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 281; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 4' | 'synthetic question 4' |
| difficulty | 0.813 | 0.813 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q005 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.177 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.052 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.073 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.073 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 229; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 5' | 'synthetic question 5' |
| difficulty | 0.913 | 0.913 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q006 factual=0, v(∅)=0.50, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.208 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.146 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 264; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 6' | 'synthetic question 6' |
| difficulty | 0.607 | 0.607 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q007 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.302 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.500 | +0.406 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.115 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.052 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 341; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 7' | 'synthetic question 7' |
| difficulty | 0.729 | 0.729 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q008 factual=0, v(∅)=0.62, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.146 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.146 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 236; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 8' | 'synthetic question 8' |
| difficulty | 0.544 | 0.544 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q009 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.156 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.281 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.219 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.094 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 268; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 9' | 'synthetic question 9' |
| difficulty | 0.935 | 0.935 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q010 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.375 | +0.375 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.188 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.125 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 279; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 10' | 'synthetic question 10' |
| difficulty | 0.816 | 0.816 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q011 factual=0, v(∅)=0.50, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.208 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.208 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 251; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 11' | 'synthetic question 11' |
| difficulty | 0.003 | 0.003 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q012 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.000 | +0.208 | | |
| retrieve | +0.625 | +0.250 | +0.458 | | |
| answer | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.333 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 296; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 12' | 'synthetic question 12' |
| difficulty | 0.857 | 0.857 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q013 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 208; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 13' | 'synthetic question 13' |
| difficulty | 0.034 | 0.034 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q014 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.312 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.125 | +0.354 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 304; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 14' | 'synthetic question 14' |
| difficulty | 0.73 | 0.73 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q015 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.312 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.271 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 273; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 15' | 'synthetic question 15' |
| difficulty | 0.176 | 0.176 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q016 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.62, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.229 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.229 | | ◆ |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.042 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 259; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 16' | 'synthetic question 16' |
| difficulty | 0.863 | 0.863 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
q017 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.312 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.500 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.104 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 327; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 17' | 'synthetic question 17' |
| difficulty | 0.541 | 0.541 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q018 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.271 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.104 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 264; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 18' | 'synthetic question 18' |
| difficulty | 0.3 | 0.3 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q019 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.250 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.188 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.187 | | |
| verify | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 274; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 19' | 'synthetic question 19' |
| difficulty | 0.423 | 0.423 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q022 factual=0, v(∅)=0.62, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.219 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.094 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 222; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 22' | 'synthetic question 22' |
| difficulty | 0.671 | 0.671 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q023 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.333 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.146 | | |
| verify | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.146 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 257; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 23' | 'synthetic question 23' |
| difficulty | 0.647 | 0.647 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q025 factual=0, v(∅)=0.62, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.312 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 206; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 25' | 'synthetic question 25' |
| difficulty | 0.384 | 0.384 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q026 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.271 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.333 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 296; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 26' | 'synthetic question 26' |
| difficulty | 0.997 | 0.997 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q027 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=0.62, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 234; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 27' | 'synthetic question 27' |
| difficulty | 0.981 | 0.981 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q029 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.75, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.250 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 234; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 29' | 'synthetic question 29' |
| difficulty | 0.65 | 0.65 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q030 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.177 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.302 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.010 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.010 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 262; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 30' | 'synthetic question 30' |
| difficulty | 0.688 | 0.688 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q031 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.500 | +0.396 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.500 | +0.396 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.042 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.042 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 315; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 31' | 'synthetic question 31' |
| difficulty | 0.389 | 0.389 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'stale_fact' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q032 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.188 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | |
| verify | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 202; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 32' | 'synthetic question 32' |
| difficulty | 0.135 | 0.135 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q033 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.333 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.271 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.271 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 293; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 33' | 'synthetic question 33' |
| difficulty | 0.721 | 0.721 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q034 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.156 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.344 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.281 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.094 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 285; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 34' | 'synthetic question 34' |
| difficulty | 0.525 | 0.525 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q036 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.208 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.146 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 242; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 36' | 'synthetic question 36' |
| difficulty | 0.486 | 0.486 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q037 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.000 | +0.208 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.125 | +0.333 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 276; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 37' | 'synthetic question 37' |
| difficulty | 0.889 | 0.889 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q038 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.292 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.375 | +0.146 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.250 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 293; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 38' | 'synthetic question 38' |
| difficulty | 0.934 | 0.934 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q039 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.62, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 243; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 39' | 'synthetic question 39' |
| difficulty | 0.358 | 0.358 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'irrelevant' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q040 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.292 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.250 | | |
| answer | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.312 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 265; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 40' | 'synthetic question 40' |
| difficulty | 0.572 | 0.572 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q041 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.375 | +0.156 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.750 | +0.490 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.135 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.094 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 313; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 41' | 'synthetic question 41' |
| difficulty | 0.322 | 0.322 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q042 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.229 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.500 | +0.438 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 258; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 42' | 'synthetic question 42' |
| difficulty | 0.594 | 0.594 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q043 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.146 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.271 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.146 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 251; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 43' | 'synthetic question 43' |
| difficulty | 0.338 | 0.338 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q044 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.156 | | ◆ |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.500 | +0.406 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 273; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 44' | 'synthetic question 44' |
| difficulty | 0.392 | 0.392 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q045 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.000 | +0.188 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.000 | +0.188 | | ◆ |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 263; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 45' | 'synthetic question 45' |
| difficulty | 0.89 | 0.89 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q046 factual=0, v(∅)=0.50, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.188 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.146 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 225; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 46' | 'synthetic question 46' |
| difficulty | 0.227 | 0.227 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q047 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.75, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.146 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.208 | | |
| verify | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.146 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 242; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 47' | 'synthetic question 47' |
| difficulty | 0.623 | 0.623 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q048 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.167 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.292 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 253; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 48' | 'synthetic question 48' |
| difficulty | 0.084 | 0.084 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q050 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.75, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.177 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.500 | +0.365 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.073 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.010 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 258; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 50' | 'synthetic question 50' |
| difficulty | 0.787 | 0.787 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q052 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.281 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.365 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.177 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.052 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 326; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 52' | 'synthetic question 52' |
| difficulty | 0.876 | 0.876 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q053 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.500 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 258; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 53' | 'synthetic question 53' |
| difficulty | 0.059 | 0.059 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q054 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.177 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.500 | +0.427 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.010 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.010 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 267; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 54' | 'synthetic question 54' |
| difficulty | 0.336 | 0.336 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q055 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.250 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.500 | +0.375 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.125 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 307; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 55' | 'synthetic question 55' |
| difficulty | 0.15 | 0.15 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q056 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.292 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 259; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 56' | 'synthetic question 56' |
| difficulty | 0.45 | 0.45 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q057 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.500 | +0.250 | +0.396 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.271 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 290; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 57' | 'synthetic question 57' |
| difficulty | 0.796 | 0.796 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q058 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.312 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.188 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 256; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 58' | 'synthetic question 58' |
| difficulty | 0.231 | 0.231 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q059 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.208 | | |
| answer | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.271 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 236; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 59' | 'synthetic question 59' |
| difficulty | 0.052 | 0.052 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q060 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.250 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | |
| verify | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 234; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 60' | 'synthetic question 60' |
| difficulty | 0.405 | 0.405 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q061 factual=0, v(∅)=0.50, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.188 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.188 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 250; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 61' | 'synthetic question 61' |
| difficulty | 0.199 | 0.199 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
q062 factual=0, v(∅)=0.50, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.094 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.302 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.052 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.052 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 259; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 62' | 'synthetic question 62' |
| difficulty | 0.091 | 0.091 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q063 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.292 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.292 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.250 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.042 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 301; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 63' | 'synthetic question 63' |
| difficulty | 0.58 | 0.58 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q064 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.323 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.198 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.073 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 271; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 64' | 'synthetic question 64' |
| difficulty | 0.299 | 0.299 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q066 factual=0, v(∅)=0.50, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.292 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.104 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 231; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 66' | 'synthetic question 66' |
| difficulty | 0.2 | 0.2 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q067 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.500 | +0.365 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.177 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.135 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.073 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 276; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 67' | 'synthetic question 67' |
| difficulty | 0.942 | 0.942 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q068 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.156 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.281 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.156 | | |
| verify | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.156 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 242; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 68' | 'synthetic question 68' |
| difficulty | 0.365 | 0.365 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q069 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.312 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.188 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 256; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 69' | 'synthetic question 69' |
| difficulty | 0.105 | 0.105 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q070 factual=0, v(∅)=0.50, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.135 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.260 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.094 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.010 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 242; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 70' | 'synthetic question 70' |
| difficulty | 0.629 | 0.629 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q071 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.188 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.188 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.188 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 257; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 71' | 'synthetic question 71' |
| difficulty | 0.927 | 0.927 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q072 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.125 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.625 | +0.438 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 239; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 72' | 'synthetic question 72' |
| difficulty | 0.44 | 0.44 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'stale' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q073 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.292 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.750 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 293; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 73' | 'synthetic question 73' |
| difficulty | 0.955 | 0.955 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q074 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.198 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.198 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.094 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.010 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 299; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 74' | 'synthetic question 74' |
| difficulty | 0.5 | 0.5 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q075 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.500 | +0.375 | +0.417 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.375 | +0.375 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 307; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 75' | 'synthetic question 75' |
| difficulty | 0.425 | 0.425 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q077 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.271 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.208 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.271 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 280; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 77' | 'synthetic question 77' |
| difficulty | 0.995 | 0.995 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q078 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.88, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.167 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.229 | | |
| answer | +0.375 | +0.500 | +0.417 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 277; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 78' | 'synthetic question 78' |
| difficulty | 0.949 | 0.949 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q079 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.229 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.375 | +0.354 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.208 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 280; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 79' | 'synthetic question 79' |
| difficulty | 0.46 | 0.46 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q083 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.500 | +0.271 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.375 | +0.188 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.271 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 310; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 83' | 'synthetic question 83' |
| difficulty | 0.786 | 0.786 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q086 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.75, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.188 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.375 | +0.438 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 256; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 86' | 'synthetic question 86' |
| difficulty | 0.711 | 0.711 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q089 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.500 | +0.490 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.219 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.115 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.052 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 305; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 89' | 'synthetic question 89' |
| difficulty | 0.729 | 0.729 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q090 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.375 | +0.167 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.500 | +0.250 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.208 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 276; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 90' | 'synthetic question 90' |
| difficulty | 0.927 | 0.927 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q091 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.250 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.208 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.208 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 261; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 91' | 'synthetic question 91' |
| difficulty | 0.968 | 0.968 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q093 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.50, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.500 | +0.229 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.500 | +0.229 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.042 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 290; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 93' | 'synthetic question 93' |
| difficulty | 0.864 | 0.864 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'stale' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'stale_fact' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q094 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.177 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.115 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.094 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.115 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 256; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 94' | 'synthetic question 94' |
| difficulty | 0.981 | 0.981 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q095 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.177 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.260 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.094 | | |
| verify | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.219 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 282; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 95' | 'synthetic question 95' |
| difficulty | 0.957 | 0.957 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q096 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.177 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.302 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.115 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 276; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 96' | 'synthetic question 96' |
| difficulty | 0.149 | 0.149 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q098 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
| answer | +0.375 | +0.375 | +0.375 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 223; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 98' | 'synthetic question 98' |
| difficulty | 0.89 | 0.89 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q099 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.177 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.177 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.073 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.073 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 273; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 99' | 'synthetic question 99' |
| difficulty | 0.822 | 0.822 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q100 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.146 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.500 | +0.479 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.104 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 278; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 100' | 'synthetic question 100' |
| difficulty | 0.48 | 0.48 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q101 factual=0, v(∅)=0.50, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.146 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.271 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 236; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 101' | 'synthetic question 101' |
| difficulty | 0.232 | 0.232 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q102 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=0.62, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.146 | | ◆ |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 232; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 102' | 'synthetic question 102' |
| difficulty | 0.802 | 0.802 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q103 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.219 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.500 | +0.531 | | ◆ |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.094 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 309; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 103' | 'synthetic question 103' |
| difficulty | 0.924 | 0.924 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q104 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.75, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.375 | +0.375 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 261; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 104' | 'synthetic question 104' |
| difficulty | 0.266 | 0.266 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q105 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.240 | | ◆ |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.375 | +0.198 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.094 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.094 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 297; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 105' | 'synthetic question 105' |
| difficulty | 0.539 | 0.539 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q107 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.208 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.208 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.333 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 294; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 107' | 'synthetic question 107' |
| difficulty | 0.931 | 0.931 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q108 factual=0, v(∅)=0.62, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 191; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 108' | 'synthetic question 108' |
| difficulty | 0.041 | 0.041 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q109 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.50, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.188 | | ◆ |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 262; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 109' | 'synthetic question 109' |
| difficulty | 0.732 | 0.732 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q110 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.312 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.208 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 287; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 110' | 'synthetic question 110' |
| difficulty | 0.614 | 0.614 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q111 factual=0, v(∅)=0.50, v(all)=0.88, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | ◆ |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.188 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 240; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 111' | 'synthetic question 111' |
| difficulty | 0.028 | 0.028 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q113 factual=0, v(∅)=0.62, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.167 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.292 | | |
| answer | -0.125 | +0.000 | -0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 236; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 113' | 'synthetic question 113' |
| difficulty | 0.016 | 0.016 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q115 factual=0, v(∅)=0.50, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.271 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 241; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 115' | 'synthetic question 115' |
| difficulty | 0.513 | 0.513 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q116 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.62, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.115 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.198 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.135 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.052 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 257; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 116' | 'synthetic question 116' |
| difficulty | 0.929 | 0.929 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q117 factual=0, v(∅)=0.62, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.167 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 261; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 117' | 'synthetic question 117' |
| difficulty | 0.066 | 0.066 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q118 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.260 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.198 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.073 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.094 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 268; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 118' | 'synthetic question 118' |
| difficulty | 0.841 | 0.841 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'stale' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
q120 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.198 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.260 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.135 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 273; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 120' | 'synthetic question 120' |
| difficulty | 0.344 | 0.344 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q121 factual=0, v(∅)=0.50, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.312 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.188 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 233; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 1.000 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 121' | 'synthetic question 121' |
| difficulty | 0.43 | 0.43 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q122 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.344 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.500 | +0.406 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.198 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.052 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 336; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 122' | 'synthetic question 122' |
| difficulty | 0.966 | 0.966 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q123 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.281 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.198 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.115 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 271; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 123' | 'synthetic question 123' |
| difficulty | 0.562 | 0.562 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q124 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.188 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.104 | | |
| answer | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.250 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 246; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 124' | 'synthetic question 124' |
| difficulty | 0.259 | 0.259 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q126 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.302 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.240 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.302 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.156 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 325; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 126' | 'synthetic question 126' |
| difficulty | 0.888 | 0.888 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q127 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.354 | | |
| answer | +0.375 | +0.000 | +0.229 | | |
| verify | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.146 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 245; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 127' | 'synthetic question 127' |
| difficulty | 0.226 | 0.226 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q128 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.312 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.625 | +0.438 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.250 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 284; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 128' | 'synthetic question 128' |
| difficulty | 0.125 | 0.125 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q129 factual=0, v(∅)=0.50, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.188 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 196; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 129' | 'synthetic question 129' |
| difficulty | 0.288 | 0.288 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q130 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.094 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.365 | | |
| answer | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.365 | | |
| verify | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.177 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 270; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.000 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 130' | 'synthetic question 130' |
| difficulty | 0.586 | 0.586 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q131 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=0.62, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.146 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 242; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 131' | 'synthetic question 131' |
| difficulty | 0.554 | 0.554 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q132 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.271 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.500 | +0.208 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 274; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 132' | 'synthetic question 132' |
| difficulty | 0.81 | 0.81 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q133 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.375 | +0.396 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.188 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 299; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 133' | 'synthetic question 133' |
| difficulty | 0.56 | 0.56 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q135 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.156 | | ◆ |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.375 | +0.240 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.052 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.052 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 271; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 135' | 'synthetic question 135' |
| difficulty | 0.413 | 0.413 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q136 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.75, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.135 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.219 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.240 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 268; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 136' | 'synthetic question 136' |
| difficulty | 0.818 | 0.818 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q137 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.219 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.344 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 298; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 137' | 'synthetic question 137' |
| difficulty | 0.627 | 0.627 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q140 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.240 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.500 | +0.302 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.198 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.010 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 271; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 140' | 'synthetic question 140' |
| difficulty | 0.553 | 0.553 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q142 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=0.62, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.250 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.250 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 251; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 142' | 'synthetic question 142' |
| difficulty | 0.848 | 0.848 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'wrong_entity' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'irrelevant' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'abstain' |
q143 factual=0, v(∅)=0.62, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.146 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 247; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 143' | 'synthetic question 143' |
| difficulty | 0.145 | 0.145 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q145 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.188 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.333 | | ◆ |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 309; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 145' | 'synthetic question 145' |
| difficulty | 0.91 | 0.91 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q146 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.250 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.250 | +0.375 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 268; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 146' | 'synthetic question 146' |
| difficulty | 0.043 | 0.043 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'stale_fact' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q148 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.375 | +0.458 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 262; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 148' | 'synthetic question 148' |
| difficulty | 0.415 | 0.415 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q150 factual=0, v(∅)=0.62, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.104 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.104 | | ◆ |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.104 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 273; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 150' | 'synthetic question 150' |
| difficulty | 0.01 | 0.01 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q151 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.167 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.146 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.229 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 254; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 151' | 'synthetic question 151' |
| difficulty | 0.365 | 0.365 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q153 factual=0, v(∅)=0.50, v(all)=0.62, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 217; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 153' | 'synthetic question 153' |
| difficulty | 0.653 | 0.653 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q155 factual=0, v(∅)=0.50, v(all)=0.75, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | |
| verify | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 203; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 155' | 'synthetic question 155' |
| difficulty | 0.703 | 0.703 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q156 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.500 | +0.250 | +0.375 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.187 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 302; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 156' | 'synthetic question 156' |
| difficulty | 0.944 | 0.944 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q158 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.271 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.146 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.208 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 259; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 158' | 'synthetic question 158' |
| difficulty | 0.865 | 0.865 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q159 factual=0, v(∅)=0.62, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.167 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.104 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 251; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 159' | 'synthetic question 159' |
| difficulty | 0.059 | 0.059 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q162 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.500 | +0.521 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.104 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.042 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 302; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 162' | 'synthetic question 162' |
| difficulty | 0.489 | 0.489 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q163 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.302 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.260 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 284; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 163' | 'synthetic question 163' |
| difficulty | 0.976 | 0.976 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q165 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.500 | +0.250 | +0.375 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.188 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 267; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 165' | 'synthetic question 165' |
| difficulty | 0.309 | 0.309 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q166 factual=0, v(∅)=0.50, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.250 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 245; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 166' | 'synthetic question 166' |
| difficulty | 0.27 | 0.27 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q167 factual=0, v(∅)=0.50, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 228; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 167' | 'synthetic question 167' |
| difficulty | 0.863 | 0.863 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q169 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.229 | | |
| retrieve | +0.500 | +0.250 | +0.354 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 273; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 169' | 'synthetic question 169' |
| difficulty | 0.511 | 0.511 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q170 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | |
| answer | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.312 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 260; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 170' | 'synthetic question 170' |
| difficulty | 0.344 | 0.344 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q171 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.292 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.167 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.042 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 254; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 171' | 'synthetic question 171' |
| difficulty | 0.995 | 0.995 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q172 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.188 | | |
| answer | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.250 | | |
| verify | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 214; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 172' | 'synthetic question 172' |
| difficulty | 0.316 | 0.316 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'near_miss' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q173 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.229 | | |
| retrieve | +0.750 | +0.250 | +0.500 | | |
| answer | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.250 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 318; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 173' | 'synthetic question 173' |
| difficulty | 0.183 | 0.183 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q174 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.281 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.094 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.094 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 285; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 174' | 'synthetic question 174' |
| difficulty | 0.88 | 0.88 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'vague' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'abstain' |
q175 factual=0, v(∅)=0.00, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.625 | +0.490 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.198 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.281 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.031 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 322; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.000 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 175' | 'synthetic question 175' |
| difficulty | 0.812 | 0.812 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q176 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.219 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.302 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.073 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.156 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 259; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 176' | 'synthetic question 176' |
| difficulty | 0.668 | 0.668 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q177 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.292 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.208 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.104 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.021 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 301; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 177' | 'synthetic question 177' |
| difficulty | 0.958 | 0.958 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q178 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.365 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.281 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.052 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.052 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 307; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 178' | 'synthetic question 178' |
| difficulty | 0.926 | 0.926 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q179 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.75, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.125 | | |
| retrieve | +0.000 | +0.250 | +0.125 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.188 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.188 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 254; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.125 |
| {retrieve} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 179' | 'synthetic question 179' |
| difficulty | 0.748 | 0.748 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'near_miss' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'abstain' |
q181 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=1.00, top: answer
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.177 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.219 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.240 | | |
| verify | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.240 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 257; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 181' | 'synthetic question 181' |
| difficulty | 0.247 | 0.247 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q182 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.167 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.188 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.188 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.083 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 271; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 182' | 'synthetic question 182' |
| difficulty | 0.141 | 0.141 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q183 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.500 | +0.396 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.208 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.083 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.125 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 307; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 183' | 'synthetic question 183' |
| difficulty | 0.67 | 0.67 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q184 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=0.88, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.115 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.240 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.073 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.073 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 225; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 184' | 'synthetic question 184' |
| difficulty | 0.715 | 0.715 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'stale_fact' | 'correct' |
q185 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=0.75, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.250 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.125 | +0.250 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | -0.125 | -0.062 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.062 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 259; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 185' | 'synthetic question 185' |
| difficulty | 0.167 | 0.167 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q187 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.375 | +0.260 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.198 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.000 | +0.073 | | |
| verify | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.219 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 256; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.250 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.625 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 187' | 'synthetic question 187' |
| difficulty | 0.91 | 0.91 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'hallucinated' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q188 factual=0, v(∅)=0.38, v(all)=1.00, top: retrieve
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.240 | | |
| retrieve | +0.250 | +0.250 | +0.281 | | |
| answer | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.052 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.052 | | |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 256; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite} | 0.500 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.750 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 1.000 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 188' | 'synthetic question 188' |
| difficulty | 0.561 | 0.561 |
| rewrite | 'wrong_entity' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'irrelevant' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'hallucinated' | 'correct' |
q191 factual=0, v(∅)=0.25, v(all)=1.00, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.312 | | |
| retrieve | +0.375 | +0.250 | +0.312 | | |
| answer | +0.125 | +0.125 | +0.125 | | |
| verify | +0.000 | +0.000 | +0.000 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 262; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.875 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 1.000 |
| {verify} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.625 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.875 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.750 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 1.000 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 191' | 'synthetic question 191' |
| difficulty | 0.526 | 0.526 |
| rewrite | 'precise' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'gold' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
q192 factual=0, v(∅)=0.12, v(all)=0.88, top: rewrite
| step | fix alone | leave-one-out | Shapley | Shapley bar (±CI) | last touch |
|---|
| rewrite | +0.250 | +0.375 | +0.292 | | |
| retrieve | +0.125 | +0.250 | +0.167 | | |
| answer | +0.250 | +0.125 | +0.167 | | |
| verify | +0.250 | +0.000 | +0.125 | | ◆ |
exact; 16 coalitions; cost 270; exhaustive
Coalition values v(S) (S = set of fixed steps):
| {} | 0.125 |
| {rewrite} | 0.375 |
| {retrieve} | 0.250 |
| {rewrite, retrieve} | 0.500 |
| {answer} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer} | 0.875 |
| {verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, verify} | 0.750 |
| {answer, verify} | 0.375 |
| {rewrite, answer, verify} | 0.625 |
| {retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.500 |
| {rewrite, retrieve, answer, verify} | 0.875 |
Outputs: factual vs. all-fixed
| value | factual | all fixes |
|---|
| question | 'synthetic question 192' | 'synthetic question 192' |
| difficulty | 0.523 | 0.523 |
| rewrite | 'vague' | 'precise' |
| retrieve | 'stale' | 'gold' |
| answer | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
| verify | 'abstain' | 'correct' |
… 4 more cases omitted.