Algebraic Geometry

Fourteen modules on varieties, schemes, cohomology, curves and surfaces, each taught in the format that fits it best. Drag curves and lines, play an animated blow-up, work through an example one step at a time, then check yourself with concept questions and practice problems.

Follows the chapter order of R. Hartshorne, Algebraic Geometry, Graduate Texts in Mathematics 52 (Springer, 1977). The modules cover Chapter I §1–7, Chapter II §1–8, Chapter III (one module, on the cohomology of projective space), Chapter IV §1–5 and Chapter V §1–4. Chapter and section numbers refer to that book; the questions and examples here are written for this page. Exercises from the book appear at the end of each module, with their numbers from the book and their statements restated in our own words.

InteractiveHartshorne, Ch. I §1: Affine Varieties

Affine varieties and the Zariski topology

An affine variety is the set of common zeros of some polynomials. The subject starts from a dictionary between such sets and ideals of the polynomial ring. The Nullstellensatz says exactly how faithful that dictionary is, and the explorer shows what the ideal knows that the picture does not.

The idea

Fix an algebraically closed field k, and write A=k[x1,…,xn] and An=kn.

Algebraic sets. For T⊆A let Z(T)={P∈An:f(P)=0 for all f∈T}. For Y⊆An let I(Y)={f∈A:f(P)=0 for all P∈Y}. The sets Z(T) are the closed sets of the Zariski topology, because Z(a)∪Z(b)=Z(ab) and ⋂iZ(ai)=Z(∑iai).
Affine variety. An irreducible closed subset Y of An, meaning one that is not the union of two proper closed subsets. Its coordinate ring is A(Y)=A/I(Y), and the dimension of Y as a topological space equals the Krull dimension of A(Y).
Nullstellensatz. For every ideal a⊆A,  I(Z(a))=a. So Z and I are inverse, inclusion-reversing bijections between radical ideals and closed sets. Prime ideals correspond to varieties and maximal ideals to points.
A coarse topology. On A1 the closed sets are the finite sets and A1 itself, so any two nonempty open sets meet. The Zariski topology is not Hausdorff.

In the explorer k=C, but only the real points can be drawn. Slide the line and compare the ideal (f,g) with what you see.

Explore

Z(f) Z(g) points of Z(f,g)
The curves
Show

Worked example

Let Y=Z(xy, xz, yz)⊂A3. Find its irreducible components, their prime ideals, and I(Y).

  1. Which points satisfy all three equations?

    The products of every pair of coordinates vanish, so at least two of x,y,z are zero. That is the union of the three coordinate axes: Y=Z(y,z)∪Z(x,z)∪Z(x,y).

  2. Why is each axis irreducible, and what is its ideal?

    The x-axis is Z(y,z), and A/(y,z)≅k[x] is a domain, so (y,z) is prime. A prime ideal is radical, so the Nullstellensatz gives I(Z(y,z))=(y,z), and prime ideals correspond to irreducible sets. The same holds for the other two axes.

  3. Are these the components, with nothing redundant?

    None of the three axes contains another, and each is irreducible. A decomposition of a noetherian space into irreducible closed sets with no redundancy is unique, so these are the irreducible components. Y has dimension 1.

  4. Show that I(Y)=(xy,xz,yz). In particular, the defining ideal is already radical.

    I(Y)=(y,z)∩(x,z)∩(x,y). All of these are monomial ideals, so their intersection is spanned by the monomials lying in all three. A monomial lies in (y,z) if it contains y or z, and so on. A monomial in all three therefore contains at least two different variables, so it is divisible by xy, xz or yz.

    In A(Y) we have x¯y¯=0 with x¯,y¯≠0. The zero divisors are the algebraic trace of the fact that Y is reducible.

Check your understanding

Which subsets of A1 are closed in the Zariski topology?

  1. The finite subsets, and A1 itself.
  2. Closed intervals [a,b] and their finite unions.An interval is infinite, and a nonzero polynomial has only finitely many roots. Also, k is algebraically closed, so it carries no ordering.
  3. Every subset.Then every infinite proper subset would be the zero set of some polynomials. A nonzero polynomial has finitely many roots.
k[x] is a principal ideal domain, so every closed set is Z(f) for one polynomial f. That is a finite set if f≠0 and all of A1 if f=0. This is the cofinite topology.

Over k=C, what is Z(x2+y2−1, x−2)?

  1. The empty set.Over R, yes. Over C, substitute x=2 and solve for y.
  2. Two points.
  3. One point, where the line is tangent to the circle.The line x=a is tangent only for a=±1.
With x=2, y2=−3, so the points are (2,±i3). The ideal is proper, so by the Nullstellensatz Z cannot be empty over an algebraically closed field. In the explorer, slide a past 1.

Let a=(x2, y)⊆k[x,y]. What is I(Z(a))?

  1. (x2,y)The function x vanishes at every point of Z(a), but x∉a.
  2. (x,y)
  3. (1)Z(a) is not empty: the origin is in it.
Z(a) is the origin, whose ideal is (x,y)=a. The ideal (x2,y) records that the parabola y=x2 and the line y=0 are tangent there: it equals (y−x2, y).

Practice

Irreducible, or not?Factor first

Decide whether each of Z(y2−x2), Z(y2−x3) and Z(x2+y2) in A2 is irreducible (k algebraically closed of characteristic 0).

Hint

In the UFD k[x,y], Z(f) is irreducible exactly when f is a power of a single irreducible polynomial.

Solution

y2−x2=(y−x)(y+x): two lines, reducible. y2−x3 is irreducible: as a polynomial in y it is monic of degree 2, so a factorisation would be (y−p(x))(y+p(x)) with p2=x3, which is impossible. So the cusp is irreducible. Finally x2+y2=(x+iy)(x−iy), two lines through the origin. (Over R the polynomial is irreducible but its real zero set is a single point. The dictionary only works over an algebraically closed field.)

Dense open setsThe Zariski topology is coarse

Show that every nonempty open subset U of an irreducible space Y is dense. Deduce that a polynomial on A2 that vanishes on the complement of the line x=0 is zero.

Solution

Y=U―∪(Y∖U) is a union of two closed sets, and Y∖U≠Y. Irreducibility forces U―=Y. For the second part: {f=0} is closed and contains the dense open set {x≠0} of the irreducible space A2, so it is all of A2. Then f∈I(A2)=0 (an infinite field has no nonzero polynomial vanishing everywhere).

From Hartshorne, Algebraic Geometry (Springer GTM 52, 1977)

Numbers match the book. Each question is restated in our own words; the hints and solutions are written for this page.

Exercise I.1.1Coordinate rings of conics

(a) Let Y⊂A2 be the curve y=x2. Show A(Y) is a polynomial ring in one variable. (b) Let Z be the curve xy=1. Show A(Z) is not a polynomial ring in one variable. (c) Show that the coordinate ring of any irreducible conic W=Z(f) is isomorphic to A(Y) or to A(Z), and say which.

Hint

(b) Look at units. (c) After an affine change of coordinates, everything depends on the degree-2 part of f.

Solution

(a) k[x,y]/(y−x2)≅k[x], via y↦x2.

(b) A(Z)=k[x,y]/(xy−1)≅k[x,x−1], in which x is a non-constant unit. In k[t] the only units are the nonzero constants, so the two rings are not isomorphic.

(c) Write f=q+ℓ+c, with q the quadratic part. Over the algebraically closed field k, q is either the square of a linear form or a product of two independent linear forms.

If q=u2, take u as a coordinate x. Irreducibility forces the linear part to involve a second independent coordinate, which can be called y after a change of variables, so f becomes y−x2 and A(W)≅k[x].

If q=uv with u,v independent, a translation removes the linear terms and f becomes uv−c′. Irreducibility forces c′≠0, and after rescaling f=xy−1, so A(W)≅k[x,x−1].

Geometrically: one point at infinity (a parabola) gives A1; two points at infinity give A1∖{0}.

Exercise I.1.3Three components

Let Y⊂A3 be defined by x2−yz and xz−x. Show Y is a union of three irreducible components; describe them and find their prime ideals.

Hint

xz−x=x(z−1).

Solution

Either x=0 or z=1.

If x=0, then yz=0, giving two lines: the z-axis {x=y=0} and the y-axis {x=z=0}.

If z=1, then y=x2, giving a parabola in the plane z=1.

The prime ideals are (x,y), (x,z) and (z−1,y−x2). Each is prime because its quotient is k[z], k[y] or k[x]. None of the three curves contains another, so these are the components.

InteractiveHartshorne, Ch. I §2: Projective Varieties

Projective space and points at infinity

The affine plane is missing points: parallel lines never meet, and a hyperbola runs off in two directions. Projective space adds the missing points. Once they are there, ellipses, parabolas and hyperbolas turn out to be the same curve seen from different charts.

The idea

Projective space. Pn is the set of lines through the origin in kn+1. A point is written [a0:⋯:an], and [a]=[λa] for λ∈k∗. A homogeneous polynomial F of degree d has F(λa)=λdF(a), so it has no values on Pn, but its zero set is well defined.
Projective variety. The closed sets of Pn are the zero sets Z(T) of sets T of homogeneous polynomials. A projective variety is an irreducible closed subset. Homogeneous radical ideals other than (1) and the irrelevant ideal (x0,…,xn) correspond to nonempty closed sets.
Affine charts. Ui={xi≠0} is homeomorphic to An by dividing by xi. With coordinates [X:Y:Z] on P2, the chart Z≠0 is the plane with x=X/Z, y=Y/Z, and its complement {Z=0} is the line at infinity.
Projective closure of a plane curve. If f∈k[x,y] has degree d, the closure of Z(f) in P2 is Z(F), where F(X,Y,Z)=Zdf(X/Z,Y/Z) is the homogenisation. Its points at infinity are the [x:y:0] with fd(x,y)=0, where fd is the top-degree part of f.
For ideals, homogenise everything. The closure of Z(a) is cut out by the homogenisations of all elements of a. Homogenising a set of generators is not always enough.

The explorer draws the real projective plane as a disc: the affine plane fills the interior, and the boundary circle is the line at infinity, with opposite points of the circle identified. The second picture is the chart Y≠0, where the old line at infinity is an ordinary line.

Explore

Examples
The whole of P2(R). line at infinity Z=0 the line Y=0 points at infinity
The chart Y≠0, coordinates (X/Y, Z/Y). Here Z=0 is the teal line, and the gold line Y=0 is at infinity.

Worked example

The affine curve y=x3 is smooth. Find its projective closure, its points at infinity, and what the closure looks like there.

  1. Homogenise f=y−x3.

    The degree is 3, so F=Z3(Y/Z−(X/Z)3)=YZ2−X3.

  2. Find the points at infinity.

    Set Z=0: then X3=0, so X=0 and the only point is [0:1:0]. This matches the rule: the top-degree part of f is −x3, which vanishes only in the direction (0,1).

  3. Look at the closure near [0:1:0] in the chart Y≠0, with coordinates u=X/Y, w=Z/Y.

    Dividing F by Y3 gives w2=u3. The point at infinity is (u,w)=(0,0), and there the curve is a cusp: both partial derivatives of w2−u3 vanish. A smooth affine curve can have a singular projective closure.

  4. Compare with the parabola y=x2.

    The closure is YZ=X2, again with the single point [0:1:0] at infinity. In the chart Y≠0 it reads w=u2, which is smooth at the origin with tangent line w=0. That line is Z=0: the parabola is tangent to the line at infinity, as the explorer shows.

Check your understanding

Where do the closures of the parallel lines y=x and y=x+1 meet in P2?

  1. Nowhere: they are parallel.Any two distinct lines in P2 meet in exactly one point.
  2. At [1:1:0]
  3. At [0:0:1]That is the origin of the affine chart, which lies on only the first line.
Homogenise: Y=X and Y=X+Z. Subtracting gives Z=0, and then X=Y. The common point is the point at infinity in their shared direction (1,1). Try "Parallel lines" in the explorer.

Which affine conic has a projective closure that is tangent to the line at infinity?

  1. An ellipseAn ellipse has no real points at infinity. Over C it meets the line at infinity in two distinct points.
  2. A parabola
  3. A hyperbolaA hyperbola meets the line at infinity in two distinct points, its two asymptote directions.
The points at infinity are the zeros of the degree-2 part. For a parabola that part is a perfect square, such as x2, so there is one point at infinity and it counts twice: the closure meets the line at infinity with multiplicity 2 there, which is tangency.

Why does F=X+Y2 not define a subset of P2?

  1. Whether F vanishes depends on the representative: F(1,1,0)=2 but F(−1,−1,0)=0, and [1:1:0]=[−1:−1:0].
  2. Because F is reducible.X+Y2 is irreducible. The problem is that it is not homogeneous.
  3. Because no polynomial defines a subset of P2.Homogeneous polynomials do: their zero sets are well defined.
Only homogeneous polynomials scale by a single factor λd under a↦λa, and that is what makes "F(a)=0" independent of the representative.

Practice

A hyperbola is a parabolaChanging the chart

Show that the closure of xy=1 is Z(XY−Z2), find its points at infinity, and find a chart in which the closure looks like a parabola.

Solution

Homogenising gives XY=Z2. At Z=0, XY=0, so the points at infinity are [1:0:0] and [0:1:0], the directions of the two asymptotes. In the chart X≠0, with v=Y/X and w=Z/X, the equation reads v=w2: a parabola, which meets the line at infinity of that chart only at [0:1:0], tangentially.

The cubic at infinityA flex on the line at infinity

Find the points at infinity of the closure of y2=x3−x. Show the closure is smooth there and that the line at infinity meets it there with multiplicity 3.

Solution

F=Y2Z−X3+XZ2. At Z=0, X3=0, so the only point is [0:1:0]. In the chart Y=1 with u=X/Y, w=Z/Y: w−u3+uw2=0. The partial derivative in w is 1 at the origin, so the point is smooth, with tangent line w=0, the line at infinity. Restricting to w=0 leaves −u3=0, a triple root, so the line at infinity meets the curve there with multiplicity 3: the point is a flex.

From Hartshorne, Algebraic Geometry (Springer GTM 52, 1977)

Numbers match the book. Each question is restated in our own words; the hints and solutions are written for this page.

Exercise I.2.9Projective closure

Let Y⊂An be an affine variety and Y¯ its closure in Pn. (a) Show I(Y¯) is generated by the homogenisations β(I(Y)). (b) For the twisted cubic Y⊂A3, find generators of I(Y) and I(Y¯), and show that the homogenisations of a generating set of I(Y) need not generate I(Y¯).

Hint

Dehomogenise a form vanishing on Y¯; it is x0e times the homogenisation of its dehomogenisation.

Solution

(a) If f∈I(Y), then β(f) vanishes on Y (identified with Y¯∩{x0≠0}), hence on its closure. Conversely, let F∈I(Y¯) be homogeneous and f=F(1,x1,…,xn). Then f∈I(Y) and F=x0eβ(f) for some e, so F lies in the ideal generated by β(I(Y)).

(b) Y={(t,t2,t3)} and I(Y)=(y−x2,z−x3). With w the new coordinate, Y¯ is the twisted cubic in P3, and

I(Y¯)=(x2−wy, xy−wz, y2−xz).

The homogenised generators are x2−wy and w2z−x3. The only degree-2 elements of the ideal they generate are multiples of x2−wy. But xy−wz∈I(Y¯) has degree 2 and is not such a multiple. So they don't generate I(Y¯).

Exercise I.2.16Intersections behave badly

(a) Show the intersection of the quadrics x2−yw=0 and xy−zw=0 in P3 is the union of a twisted cubic and a line. (b) For the conic C:x2−yz=0 and the line L:y=0 in P2, show C∩L is one point P but I(C)+I(L)≠I(P).

Hint

(a) Split into w=0 and w≠0.

Solution

(a) If w=0, then x2=0 and xy=0, so x=0: this is the line {x=w=0}. If w=1, then y=x2 and z=xy=x3: this is the affine twisted cubic (x,x2,x3), whose closure is the twisted cubic. (Its only point at infinity, (0:0:1:0), lies on the line.)

(b) y=0 and x2=0 give P=(0:0:1). But I(C)+I(L)=(x2−yz,y)=(x2,y), which doesn't contain x, whereas I(P)=(x,y). The line is tangent to the conic at P, and the sum of the ideals records the multiplicity 2.

Animated lessonHartshorne, Ch. I §3: Morphisms · §4: Rational Maps

Rational maps and blowing up

Morphisms are maps given locally by polynomials. Rational maps only need to be defined on a dense open set, and two varieties are birational when such maps go both ways. Blowing up a point is the basic birational map, and it pulls apart the branches of a singular curve.

The idea

Regular functions. A function on a variety Y is regular at P if near P it equals g/h with g,h polynomials and h≠0. This gives the ring O(Y) of regular functions, the local ring OP,Y and the function field K(Y). For affine Y: O(Y)≅A(Y), OP,Y≅A(Y)mP, and K(Y) is the fraction field of A(Y).
Affine varieties are rings. A morphism is a continuous map that pulls regular functions back to regular functions. X↦A(X) is an arrow-reversing equivalence between affine varieties over k and finitely generated k-algebras that are domains.
Rational maps. A rational map φ:X⇢Y is a morphism on some nonempty open set, with two such identified when they agree on an open set. It is birational if it has a rational inverse. X and Y are birational exactly when K(X)≅K(Y) as k-algebras.
Blowing up the origin of A2. X={((x,y),[u:v]):xv=yu}⊂A2×P1, with π:X→A2 the projection. Over a point other than the origin there is one point of X; over the origin there is a whole P1, the exceptional line E, one point per line through 0. On the chart u≠0 the coordinates are (x,t) with t=v/u, and y=tx.
Strict transform. For a curve C through the origin, C~ is the closure of π−1(C∖{0}). Its points on E are the tangent directions of C at the origin.

Watch

Singular curve
The plane, coordinates (x,y). the curve a line through 0
The blow-up, coordinates (x,t) with y=tx. exceptional line E
  1. A plane curve whose only singular point is the origin.
  2. Every point other than the origin lies on exactly one line through the origin. Label the line by its slope t=y/x. In the right picture that line becomes the horizontal line at height t.
  3. Send (x,y) to (x,y/x). Away from x=0 this is invertible, with inverse (x,t)↦(x,tx). Follow a point along the curve and its image.
  4. The origin is replaced by the line E={x=0}, one point for each slope. Substituting y=tx factors the equation as x2⋅(strict transform)=0.
  5. The strict transform meets E at the tangent directions of the curve at the origin.

Worked example

Show that the conic C:x2−2y2=1 is birational to A1 by projecting from the point P=(1,0), and that the closure C¯⊂P2 is isomorphic to P1.

  1. Intersect C with the line y=t(x−1) through P. What equation do you get, and which root do you already know?

    Substituting: x2−1−2t2(x−1)2=0, that is (x−1)[(x+1)−2t2(x−1)]=0. The root x=1 is P itself.

  2. Find the second intersection point.

    x=2t2+12t2−1,y=t(x−1)=2t2t2−1.

    Check: x2−2y2=(2t2+1)2−8t2(2t2−1)2=(2t2−1)2(2t2−1)2=1.

  3. Why is this birational?

    The map t↦(x,y) is defined for 2t2≠1, and on C∖{P} the inverse is t=y/(x−1), a rational function on C. The two maps are inverse where both are defined, so K(C)=k(t).

  4. What happens at t=±1/2 and as t→∞? Use homogeneous coordinates.

    Clearing denominators, t↦[2t2+1:2t:2t2−1]. Writing t=s0/s1, this becomes [s0:s1]↦[2s02+s12:2s0s1:2s02−s12], and the three entries vanish together only when s0=s1=0. So it is a morphism on all of P1. At t=±1/2 the image is [±2:1:0]: the line through P is parallel to an asymptote and the second point is at infinity. At t=∞ the image is [2:0:2]=P: the vertical line x=1 is tangent at P. So P1→C¯ is a bijective morphism, with inverse given by projection from P (extended by the tangent line at P). It is an isomorphism.

Check your understanding

For affine varieties X and Y, a morphism X→Y is the same thing as:

  1. a k-algebra homomorphism A(Y)→A(X)
  2. a k-algebra homomorphism A(X)→A(Y)The arrow reverses: a map X→Y pulls functions on Y back to functions on X.
  3. a map that is continuous in the Zariski topologyToo weak: any bijection A1→A1 is a homeomorphism for the cofinite topology, and most are not morphisms.
φ gives φ∗:A(Y)→A(X), f↦f∘φ. Conversely, a homomorphism is determined by where it sends the coordinate functions yj, and those images are the components of a polynomial map.

Choose "Node" in the animation. In how many points does the strict transform meet the exceptional line E?

  1. OneThat is what happens for the cusp, which has a single tangent direction.
  2. Two
  3. NoneThe curve passes through the origin, so the closure of its preimage must reach E.
The node y2=x2(1−x2) has two tangent lines y=±x at the origin, and the strict transform t2+x2=1 meets E={x=0} at t=±1, one point for each. The two branches no longer meet.

Are A1 and A1∖{0} birational? Are they isomorphic?

  1. Birational, but not isomorphic.
  2. Isomorphic, by x↦1/x.1/x is not defined at 0∈A1.
  3. Neither: one is affine and the other is not.A1∖{0}≅Z(xy−1) is affine. And birationality only sees a dense open set.
Both have function field k(x). But O(A1∖{0})=k[x,x−1] has the nonconstant unit x, while the only units of k[x] are constants, so the rings, and therefore the varieties, are not isomorphic.

Practice

Blowing up linesDirections become points

Show that the strict transform of the line y=mx is the line t=m, and conclude that two lines through the origin with different slopes have disjoint strict transforms.

Solution

Substituting y=tx gives tx−mx=x(t−m). The factor x is E, and the rest is the line t=m, which meets E at the single point t=m. Two different slopes give the disjoint lines t=m and t=m′. (Vertical lines live in the other chart x=sy.)

Repeated blowing upA family of cusps

How many blow-ups of the origin are needed to make the strict transform of y2=x2k+1 smooth, for k≥1?

Hint

Substitute y=tx and see which curve you get.

Solution

t2x2=x2k+1 gives the strict transform t2=x2k−1, a curve of the same shape with k lowered by one. After k blow-ups we reach t2=x, which is smooth. So k blow-ups are needed. (The ordinary cusp k=1 needs one.)

From Hartshorne, Algebraic Geometry (Springer GTM 52, 1977)

Numbers match the book. Each question is restated in our own words; the hints and solutions are written for this page.

Exercise I.4.4Rational curves

(a) Show any conic in P2 is rational. (b) Show the cuspidal cubic y2=x3 is rational. (c) For the nodal cubic y2z=x2(x+z), show projection from P=(0:0:1) to the line z=0 induces a birational map to P1.

Hint

Project from a point of the curve: each line through that point meets the curve in one further point.

Solution

(a) An irreducible conic is projectively equivalent to xz=y2, which is the image of P1 under (s:t)↦(s2:st:t2). This map is an isomorphism, with inverse (x:y:z)↦(x:y) or (y:z) on overlapping open sets.

(b) t↦(t2,t3) and (x,y)↦y/x are inverse rational maps.

(c) In the affine chart z=1, projection from the origin is (x,y)↦t=y/x. Substituting y=tx gives t2x2=x2(x+1), so x=t2−1 and y=t(t2−1). So t↦(t2−1,t3−t) is a rational inverse, and the projection is birational.

Exercise I.4.10Blowing up the cusp

Let Y be the cuspidal cubic y2=x3 in A2. Blow up O=(0,0); let E be the exceptional curve and Y~ the strict transform. Show E meets Y~ in one point and Y~≅A1. Show φ:Y~→Y is bijective and bicontinuous but not an isomorphism.

Hint

Use the chart y=ux.

Solution

In the chart y=ux, the total transform is x2(u2−x)=0. So E={x=0} and Y~={x=u2}, which meets E only at u=0. (In the other chart, x=vy gives y2=v3y3, whose strict transform 1=v3y misses E.)

Y~≅A1 via u, and φ(u)=(u2,u3). This is bijective (u=y/x away from O, and u=0 over O). It is a homeomorphism because both curves carry the cofinite topology. It is not an isomorphism: φ∗ maps A(Y)=k[t2,t3] onto a proper subring of k[t]. Equivalently, Y is singular at O and Y~ is not.

Exercise I.5.6Resolving curve singularities by blowing up

(a) Show that blowing up resolves the node and the cusp. (b) For a node, show Y~ meets E in two points, corresponding to the two tangent directions. (c) For the tacnode x2=x4+y4, show the blow-up has a node over O, so a second blow-up resolves it. (d) For y3=x5, show O is a triple point, that one blow-up gives a double point (identify it), and that a further blow-up resolves it.

Hint

Write y=ux or x=vy and divide by the right power of the exceptional coordinate.

Solution

(a, b) Node y2=x2(x+1): with y=ux, the strict transform is u2=x+1, which is smooth and meets E={x=0} at u=±1, the slopes of the two branches. The cusp was done in Exercise 4.10.

(c) Here the tangent direction is x=0, so use x=vy: v2y2=v4y4+y4 gives the strict transform v2=y2(v4+1). Its lowest-order part at (0,0) is v2−y2: a node. By (a), one more blow-up resolves it.

(d) The lowest-degree term of y3−x5 is y3: multiplicity 3, with the single tangent y=0. With y=ux: u3x3=x5 gives u3=x2, an ordinary cusp (a double point). Blowing up once more resolves it, as in (a).

InteractiveHartshorne, Ch. I §5: Nonsingular Varieties · §6: Nonsingular Curves

Singular points of curves

A point of a variety is nonsingular when the variety looks like affine space there to first order. For a plane curve the test is two partial derivatives. In the cubic below a node, a cusp and an isolated point appear exactly when roots collide.

The idea

Jacobian criterion. Let Y⊆An be an affine variety of dimension r with I(Y)=(f1,…,ft). Y is nonsingular at P if the matrix (∂fi/∂xj(P)) has rank n−r. For a plane curve Z(f), with f irreducible, P is singular exactly when f(P)=∂f∂x(P)=∂f∂y(P)=0.
It is intrinsic. Y is nonsingular at P if and only if OP,Y is a regular local ring: dimk⁡m/m2=dim⁡OP,Y. The singular points form a proper closed subset of Y.
Multiplicity and tangent cone. Move P to the origin and write f=fr+fr+1+… with fi homogeneous of degree i and fr≠0. Then r is the multiplicity of P, and the linear factors of fr are the tangent directions. A node is a double point with two distinct tangents; a cusp here means a double point with a single repeated tangent.
Nonsingular curves. At a nonsingular point P of a curve, OP is a discrete valuation ring, so every nonzero rational function has an order of vanishing ordP⁡(f)∈Z. Nonsingular projective curves, with dominant morphisms, are equivalent to function fields of transcendence degree 1 over k, with arrows reversed.

The explorer uses y2=g(x)=(x−e1)(x−e2)(x−e3). Here ∂f∂y=2y and ∂f∂x=−g′(x), so a singular point needs y=0 and g(x)=g′(x)=0: a repeated root of g.

Explore

Drag the three roots e1,e2,e3 along the x-axis. singular point tangent cone
Jump to

Worked example

Find all singular points of the affine curve C: (x2+y2)2=2(x2−y2) over C, and the tangent cone at each. Then look at the points at infinity.

  1. Write f=(x2+y2)2−2(x2−y2) and compute both partial derivatives.

    ∂f∂x=4x(x2+y2−1),∂f∂y=4y(x2+y2+1).
  2. Solve f=∂xf=∂yf=0. Treat y=0 and x2+y2=−1 separately.

    If y=0: ∂xf=4x(x2−1) vanishes at x=0,±1, and f(±1,0)=1−2=−1≠0, while f(0,0)=0. If x2+y2=−1: ∂xf=−8x, so x=0 and y=±i, but f(0,±i)=1−2=−1≠0. The only affine singular point is the origin.

  3. What is the tangent cone at the origin?

    The lowest-degree part of f is −2(x2−y2)=−2(x−y)(x+y). So the origin is a node with tangents y=±x.

  4. Homogenise and find the points at infinity. Are they singular?

    F=(X2+Y2)2−2Z2(X2−Y2). At Z=0, (X2+Y2)2=0, giving [1:±i:0]. Near [1:i:0], set X=1, Y=i+w: then 1+Y2=2iw+w2, so F=(2iw+w2)2−2Z2(2−2iw−w2)=−4w2−4Z2+…. The lowest form −4(w2+Z2) has two distinct factors: another node, and the same happens at [1:−i:0]. So C¯ is a quartic with three nodes. (A plane quartic has arithmetic genus 3, and each node lowers the genus by one, so C¯ is a rational curve.)

Check your understanding

Is the affine curve y2=x3+x2+x singular anywhere over C?

  1. Yes, at the origin.The origin is on the curve, but ∂f∂x=−(3x2+2x+1) equals −1 there.
  2. No, it is nonsingular.
  3. Yes, at two complex points.A singular point of y2=g(x) needs a repeated root of g. Are the roots of x(x2+x+1) distinct?
g=x(x2+x+1) has the three distinct roots 0 and −1±i32, so g and g′ have no common root and the curve is nonsingular.

On the parabola y=x2, what is ordP⁡(y) at P=(0,0)?

  1. 1y is a coordinate on the plane, but along this curve it vanishes faster than a local parameter.
  2. 2
  3. 0Order 0 would mean y(P)≠0, but P has y=0.
The point is nonsingular and x is a local parameter (a generator of the maximal ideal of the DVR OP). On the curve y=x2, so ordP⁡(y)=2: the tangent line y=0 meets the parabola with multiplicity 2.

Over R, y2=x2(x−1) has an isolated real point at the origin. Over C, the origin is:

  1. a nonsingular pointBoth partial derivatives vanish there.
  2. a node, with tangents y=±ix
  3. a cuspThe tangent cone y2+x2 has two distinct factors over C.
f=y2+x2−x3, whose lowest form is y2+x2=(y−ix)(y+ix). The two branches are complex conjugate, so only their common real point is visible. In the explorer, use "Isolated point".

Practice

A one-parameter familyNode, cusp, isolated point

For each λ∈R, describe the singular point of y2=x3+λx2 and its tangent cone, over R and over C.

Solution

The only singular point is the origin, of multiplicity 2, with tangent cone y2−λx2. For λ>0: a node with real tangents y=±λx. For λ=0: a cusp, tangent cone y2=0. For λ<0: over C a node with tangents y=±i−λx; over R the origin is an isolated point.

Smooth, then singular at infinityCheck the closure too

Show that y2=x4+1 is a nonsingular affine curve, but that its projective closure is singular at a point at infinity. Find the tangent cone there.

Solution

Affine: ∂f∂x=−4x3, ∂f∂y=2y vanish together only at the origin, which is not on the curve. Closure: F=Y2Z2−X4−Z4. At Z=0, X=0, so the only point at infinity is [0:1:0]. In the chart Y=1: z2−x4−z4=0. Its lowest form is z2, so the point has multiplicity 2 with a single tangent z=0 counted twice. (It is a tacnode: two smooth branches z≈±x2 tangent to each other.)

From Hartshorne, Algebraic Geometry (Springer GTM 52, 1977)

Numbers match the book. Each question is restated in our own words; the hints and solutions are written for this page.

Exercise I.5.1Four plane curve singularities

Locate the singular points (char k≠2) of (a) x2=x4+y4; (b) xy=x6+y6; (c) x3=y2+x4+y4; (d) x2y+xy2=x4+y4. Which picture is which: tacnode, node, cusp, triple point?

Hint

Solve f=fx=fy=0. The shape at the origin is read from the lowest-degree part of f.

Solution

In each case the only singular point is the origin. For example, in (a), fy=−4y3 forces y=0, then fx=2x−4x3 gives x=0 or x2=12, and f(±1/2,0)=14≠0. In (b), y=6x5 and x=6y5 lead to x6=y6=xy/6, so f=23xy, which forces x=y=0. Cases (c) and (d) are similar.

  • (a) Lowest part x2: a double tangent x=0, with branches x≈±y2: tacnode.
  • (b) Lowest part xy: two distinct tangents: node.
  • (c) Lowest part −y2, with the next term x3: cusp.
  • (d) Lowest part xy(x+y): three distinct tangents: ordinary triple point.

Exercise I.5.3Multiplicity of a point on a plane curve

For f=fr+fr+1+… at P=(0,0) with fr≠0, set μP(Y)=r. (a) Show P is nonsingular iff μP(Y)=1. (b) Find the multiplicity of each singular point in Exercise 5.1.

Hint

f1=fx(0)x+fy(0)y.

Solution

(a) P is nonsingular iff (fx(0),fy(0))≠(0,0) iff f1≠0 iff r=1.

(b) Tacnode 2, node 2, cusp 2, triple point 3.

Exercise I.6.2An elliptic curve is not rational

Let Y:y2=x3−x (char ≠2) and A=A(Y). (a) Show Y is nonsingular, so A is integrally closed. (b) Show k[x]⊂A is a polynomial ring and A is its integral closure in K(Y). (c) With σ:y↦−y, define N(a)=aσ(a); show N(a)∈k[x] and N is multiplicative. (d) Show the units of A are k∗, that x and y are irreducible, and that A is not a UFD. (e) Deduce Y is not rational.

Hint

N(g+hy)=g2−h2(x3−x). The two terms have degrees of different parity, so they can't cancel.

Solution

(a) A singular point would need y=0 and 3x2=1, but then x3−x=−23x≠0. The local rings of a nonsingular curve are DVRs, so A=⋂POP is integrally closed.

(b) x is transcendental. A=k[x]⊕k[x]y is a free k[x]-module, hence integral over k[x], and it is integrally closed in K, so it is the integral closure.

(c) σ preserves the equation, so it is an automorphism. For a=g+hy, N(a)=g2−h2(x3−x)∈k[x], and N is multiplicative because σ is a ring homomorphism.

(d) deg⁡N(g+hy)=max(2deg⁡g,2deg⁡h+3), since one degree is even and the other odd. If u is a unit, N(u)∈k∗, forcing h=0 and g∈k∗. The possible degrees of norms are 0,2,3,4,5,…, never 1. If x=ab with non-units a,b, then N(a)N(b)=x2 with both factors of positive degree, so both have degree 1, which is impossible. Likewise N(y)=x−x3 has degree 3, which can't split as 1+2. But y2=x(x−1)(x+1) and x∤y (if y=x(g+hy), comparing y-coefficients gives xh=1). So the irreducible x is not prime, and A is not a UFD.

(e) If Y were rational, then by Exercise 6.1 the nonsingular affine curve Y would be isomorphic to an open subset of A1, with coordinate ring a localisation k[t]g, which is a UFD. That contradicts (d).

InteractiveHartshorne, Ch. I §7: Intersections in Projective Space

Intersections and Bézout's theorem

A line meets a plane cubic in three points, always, once you count points at infinity, complex points and tangencies correctly. Drag the line and watch each of the three corrections appear.

The idea

Hilbert polynomial and degree. For a projective variety Y⊆Pn of dimension r, with homogeneous coordinate ring S(Y), the function m↦dimk⁡S(Y)m agrees for large m with a polynomial PY of degree r. Its leading coefficient is deg⁡Y/r!. A hypersurface cut out by an irreducible form of degree d has degree d.
Intersection multiplicity of plane curves. If the curves f=0 and g=0 have no common component through P, then iP=dimk⁡OP/(f,g). It is 1 exactly when P is a nonsingular point of both curves and their tangent lines differ. For a line through P, it is the multiplicity of the corresponding root of f restricted to the line.
Bézout's theorem. Plane curves of degrees d and e with no common component satisfy ∑PiP=de, the sum over all points of P2(k). More generally, if Y⊆Pn is a variety of dimension at least 1 and H a hypersurface not containing it, then ∑ji(Y,H;Zj)deg⁡Zj=deg⁡Y⋅deg⁡H, summed over the irreducible components Zj of Y∩H.
All three corrections are needed. Count points at infinity (work in P2), complex points (k algebraically closed), and multiplicities.

Explore

Drag the two points A and B that define the line. cubic line intersection points
The cubic
Try

Worked example

Intersect the circle C:x2+y2=1 with the parabola D:y=x2−1. Find every intersection point with its multiplicity and check Bézout.

  1. Eliminate x.

    From D, x2=y+1. Then y+1+y2=1, so y(y+1)=0.

  2. List the affine intersection points.

    y=0 gives x=±1: the points (±1,0). y=−1 gives x2=0: the point (0,−1), apparently twice.

  3. Compute iP at P=(0,−1) from the local ring.

    In OP/(f,g) we may use g to replace y by x2−1. Then f becomes x2+(x2−1)2−1=x4−x2=x2(x2−1). Near P, x2−1 is a unit, so OP/(f,g)≅k[x](x)/(x2), of dimension 2. The curves are tangent at P.

  4. Are there intersections at infinity? Check Bézout.

    The circle's points at infinity are [1:±i:0] and the parabola's only one is [0:1:0], so they share none. Total: 1+1+2=4=2⋅2.

Check your understanding

Two distinct circles meet in at most 2 points of the plane, but Bézout predicts 4. Where are the other two?

  1. At [1:i:0] and [1:−i:0], which lie on every circle.
  2. At complex points of the affine plane.Subtracting the two equations leaves a linear equation, so the affine intersection, real or complex, has at most 2 points.
  3. Bézout does not apply to circles.Two distinct circles are conics with no common component, so it applies.
A circle homogenises to X2+Y2+aXZ+bYZ+cZ2=0. At Z=0 that leaves X2+Y2=0, whatever the circle. So every circle passes through these two "circular points", and two circles share them.

A line through the node of y2=x2(x+2) with slope m≠±2 meets the curve at the node with multiplicity:

  1. 1At a point of multiplicity r, every line through it meets the curve with multiplicity at least r.
  2. 2
  3. 3That happens only for the two tangent lines y=±2x.
Substituting y=mx gives x2(x+2−m2)=0: a double root at the node and a third point at x=m2−2. Choose "Through the node" in the explorer.

A curve Y⊂P3 has Hilbert polynomial PY(m)=3m+1. What is its degree?

  1. 1That is the constant term, which relates to the genus, not the degree.
  2. 3
  3. 4PY(1)=4 counts independent linear forms on Y, not the degree.
For a curve (r=1) the leading coefficient deg⁡Y/1! is 3. The constant term is 1−pa, so pa=0. The twisted cubic has exactly this Hilbert polynomial.

Practice

A cubic and a hyperbolaTwo of the six points are at infinity

Find all intersections of y=x3 and xy=1 in P2, with multiplicities, and check that they add up to 6.

Solution

Affine: x⋅x3=1, so x4=1: four distinct points (ζ,ζ3) with ζ4=1, each of multiplicity 1 (two real, two complex). At infinity the cubic YZ2=X3 has only [0:1:0] and the hyperbola XY=Z2 has [1:0:0] and [0:1:0]. In the chart Y=1: z2=x3 and x=z2. Substituting gives z2−z6=z2(1−z4), so the multiplicity at [0:1:0] is 2. Total 4+2=6=3⋅2.

Two skew linesA Hilbert polynomial by counting monomials

Let Y⊂P3 be the union of the lines Z(x0,x1) and Z(x2,x3). Compute PY, deg⁡Y and 1−PY(0).

Hint

I(Y)=(x0,x1)∩(x2,x3)=(x0x2,x0x3,x1x2,x1x3). Which monomials survive in S/I(Y)?

Solution

The monomials not in I(Y) are those involving only x0,x1 or only x2,x3. In degree m≥1 there are (m+1)+(m+1) of them, so PY(m)=2m+2. Thus deg⁡Y=2 (two lines), and 1−PY(0)=−1. A negative arithmetic genus is a sign of a disconnected curve.

From Hartshorne, Algebraic Geometry (Springer GTM 52, 1977)

Numbers match the book. Each question is restated in our own words; the hints and solutions are written for this page.

Exercise I.5.4Intersection multiplicity

For plane curves Y=Z(f), Z=Z(g) with no common component and P∈A2, define (Y⋅Z)P=lengthOP/(f,g). (a) Show it is finite, and positive iff P∈Y∩Z. (b) If P∈Y, show that for all but finitely many lines L through P, (L⋅Y)P=μP(Y). (c) If Y⊂P2 has degree d and L is a line not contained in Y, show ∑P(L⋅Y)P=d.

Hint

For a line, parametrise it and reduce to the order of vanishing of a polynomial in one variable.

Solution

(a) Y∩Z is finite, so k[x,y]/(f,g) is finite-dimensional (Nullstellensatz). It is the product of its localisations at the finitely many points of Y∩Z, and OP/(f,g) is one of these factors. That factor is nonzero iff (f,g)⊆mP, i.e. iff P∈Y∩Z.

(b) Put P at the origin, L={(at,bt)}. Then OP/(f,ℓ)≅k[t](t)/(f(at,bt)), of length ordtf(at,bt). Since f(at,bt)=trfr(a,b)+O(tr+1), the length is exactly r=μP(Y) unless fr(a,b)=0. That happens only for the finitely many tangent directions.

(c) Restricting the homogeneous F to L≅P1 gives a nonzero binary form of degree d. Its zeros, with multiplicity, sum to d, and at each point the local computation in (b) identifies the multiplicity of the root with (L⋅Y)P.

Exercise I.7.2Arithmetic genus

Define pa(Y)=(−1)r(PY(0)−1) for Y of dimension r. Show (a) pa(Pn)=0; (b) a plane curve of degree d has pa=12(d−1)(d−2); (c) a hypersurface of degree d in Pn has pa=(d−1n); (d) a complete intersection of surfaces of degrees a,b in P3 has pa=12ab(a+b−4)+1; (e) for Yr⊂Pn and Zs⊂Pm embedded by Segre, pa(Y×Z)=papa′+(−1)spa(Y)+(−1)rpa(Z).

Hint

Use exact sequences of graded modules: PH(z)=(z+nn)−(z−d+nn), the Koszul resolution for (d), and PY×Z=PYPZ for (e).

Solution

(a) P(z)=(z+nn), so P(0)=1.

(b) P(z)=(z+22)−(z−d+22), so P(0)=1−(2−d2)=1−(d−1)(d−2)2, and pa=1−P(0).

(c) P(0)=1−(n−dn), and as a polynomial (n−dn)=(−1)n(d−1n). So pa=(−1)n−1(P(0)−1)=(d−1n).

(d) P(z)=(z+33)−(z+3−a3)−(z+3−b3)+(z+3−a−b3). Evaluating at 0 and simplifying gives 1−P(0)=12ab(a+b−4)+1. (Checks: a=b=2 gives 1, an elliptic quartic; a=2,b=3 gives 4.)

(e) PY(0)=1+(−1)rpa(Y), and similarly for Z. Multiply, subtract 1, and multiply by (−1)r+s.

InteractiveHartshorne, Ch. II §1: Sheaves · §2: Schemes

Sheaves and the spectrum of a ring

Schemes replace the points of a variety by the prime ideals of a ring, and its regular functions by a sheaf. The first example to understand is Spec⁡Z: its points are the primes, and an integer is a "function" whose value at p is its residue mod p.

The idea

Sheaves. A presheaf F on X assigns a group F(U) to each open U, with restriction maps compatible with inclusions. It is a sheaf if, for every open cover U=⋃Ui, a section that restricts to 0 on every Ui is 0, and sections si∈F(Ui) that agree on all overlaps glue to a section on U. The stalk FP is the direct limit of F(U) over open sets U∋P.
The spectrum. Spec⁡A is the set of prime ideals of A. Its closed sets are V(a)={p⊇a}, and the sets D(f)={p:f∉p} form a basis of open sets. The structure sheaf O has stalks Op=Ap and sections O(D(f))≅Af; in particular Γ(Spec⁡A,O)=A.
Schemes. A scheme is a locally ringed space (X,OX) in which every point has an open neighbourhood isomorphic to some Spec⁡A.

An element f∈A has a value at each point: its image f(p) in the residue field κ(p)=Ap/pAp. It vanishes at p exactly when f∈p. For A=Z: κ((p))=Fp and κ((0))=Q.

Two new features. Points need not be closed: the closure of (0) in Spec⁡Z is everything, so (0) is a generic point. And a function is not determined by its values: in Z/4 the element 2 is nonzero, yet its value at the only point (2) is 0.

Explore

Spec⁡Z, with the generic point (0) on the left and the primes up to 47. Click a prime to read off the value there. nonzero value zero (dots show the order) not defined (a pole)

Worked example

Check the sheaf axioms on Spec⁡Z for the cover by D(2) and D(3): sections on the two pieces that agree on the overlap glue to a unique global section.

  1. Why do D(2) and D(3) cover Spec⁡Z? What are the rings of sections?

    A point outside both would be a prime containing 2 and 3, hence containing 1=3−2, which is impossible. The sections are O(D(2))=Z[1/2], O(D(3))=Z[1/3], and on the overlap D(2)∩D(3)=D(6) they are Z[1/6].

  2. Take s1=m/2a∈Z[1/2] and s2=n/3b∈Z[1/3] that agree in Z[1/6]. What equation does that give?

    m/2a=n/3b in Q, so 3bm=2an.

  3. Show that s1=s2 is an integer.

    2a divides 3bm and is coprime to 3b, so 2a∣m. Hence s1∈Z, and s2=s1. The glued section is this integer, as it must be, since Γ(Spec⁡Z,O)=Z.

  4. Check the other axiom: if an integer restricts to 0 on D(2) and on D(3), is it 0?

    Yes: Z→Z[1/2] is injective. Note that both axioms are about restriction, not about values at points; the last quiz below shows why that distinction matters.

Check your understanding

What is the closure of the point (0) in Spec⁡Z?

  1. {(0)}A closed set V(a) contains (0) only if a⊆(0).
  2. All of Spec⁡Z
  3. The set of nonzero primesThat set doesn't even contain (0). And it is not closed: a nonzero integer vanishes at only finitely many primes.
The closure of {p} is V(p), and V((0)) is everything. The generic point lies in every nonempty open set, which is why the picture draws it as a cloud over the whole line.

Which points does Spec⁡C[x] have?

  1. Exactly one point for each a∈C.You are missing a prime ideal that is not maximal.
  2. The closed points (x−a), a∈C, and the generic point (0).
  3. One point for each nonconstant polynomial.Only prime ideals count, and (f) is prime exactly when f is irreducible. Over C those are linear.
C[x] is a PID, so its nonzero primes are (f) with f irreducible, which over C means f=x−a up to a unit. Add the zero ideal.

On X=Spec⁡k[x]/(x2), the section x is nonzero, yet its value at the only point of X is 0. Is that a contradiction?

  1. No. On a non-reduced scheme a section is not determined by its values.
  2. Yes, so in fact x=0 in k[x]/(x2).x≠0 there; only x2=0.
  3. No: X has a second point where x≠0.k[x]/(x2) has exactly one prime ideal, (x).
The value of x at (x) is its image in κ=k, which is 0. But x is a nonzero nilpotent. Values only see the reduced scheme; the nilpotents carry extra, infinitesimal information.

Practice

The real line as a schemePoints and residue fields of Spec ℝ[x]

Describe the points of Spec⁡R[x] and their residue fields.

Solution

(0), with residue field R(x); (x−a) for a∈R, with residue field R; and (x2+bx+c) with b2<4c, with residue field R[x]/(x2+bx+c)≅C. Each quadratic corresponds to a conjugate pair of complex roots, so the closed points are C modulo complex conjugation: the closed upper half plane.

The spectrum of a DVRTwo points, three open sets

Let R=k[x](x). List the points of Spec⁡R, the open sets, and the rings of sections over each open set.

Solution

R is a DVR, with primes (0) and m=(x). The closed point is m and the generic point is (0). The open sets are ∅, {(0)}=D(x), and the whole space. The sections are 0, Rx=k(x) and R. So the "punctured" neighbourhood already has the whole function field as its sections.

From Hartshorne, Algebraic Geometry (Springer GTM 52, 1977)

Numbers match the book. Each question is restated in our own words; the hints and solutions are written for this page.

Exercise II.1.1Sheafifying a constant presheaf

Let A be an abelian group and C the constant presheaf U↦A (for U≠∅) on X. Show its sheafification is the constant sheaf A (locally constant functions to A).

Hint

Both have stalk A everywhere, and C→A (constants to constant functions) is a morphism to a sheaf.

Solution

The map C→A induces isomorphisms on stalks, since both stalks are A (germs of locally constant functions are constants). By the universal property it factors through C+→A, which is an isomorphism on stalks between sheaves, hence an isomorphism. Concretely, a section of C+ over U is a function to A that locally agrees with a constant, i.e. a locally constant function.

Exercise II.2.1Distinguished opens are affine

For a ring A and f∈A, show (D(f),OX|D(f))≅SpecAf.

Hint

Match the topologies, then match the sheaves on the basis of distinguished opens.

Solution

Primes of Af correspond to primes of A not containing f, and this bijection SpecAf→D(f) is a homeomorphism (it sends D(g/fn) to D(fg)). For D(g)⊆D(f), OX(D(g))=Ag and OSpecAf(D(g/1))=(Af)g. These are canonically isomorphic (since f is invertible in Ag), compatibly with restrictions. An isomorphism on a basis extends to an isomorphism of sheaves.

Exercise II.2.5Spec ℤ is the final scheme

Describe SpecZ, and show every scheme has a unique morphism to it.

Hint

Morphisms X→SpecA correspond to ring maps A→Γ(X,OX).

Solution

The points are (0), the generic point whose closure is everything, and the closed points (p) for primes p. The nonempty open sets are the complements of finite sets of closed points. The local ring at (p) is Z(p), and at (0) it is Q.

Since Hom(X,SpecZ)=Hom(Z,Γ(X,OX)) and Z is the initial ring, there is exactly one morphism.

InteractiveHartshorne, Ch. II §3: First Properties of Schemes · §4: Separated and Proper Morphisms

Fibres, separated and proper morphisms

A morphism of schemes has a fibre over every point, including the generic point, and the fibre is computed as a fibre product. Over Spec⁡Z, the fibres of Spec⁡Z[i] are finite schemes that are two points, one point, or one non-reduced point, depending on p.

The idea

First properties. A scheme is reduced if no local ring has nilpotents, and integral if every OX(U), U≠∅, is a domain (equivalently, reduced and irreducible). It is noetherian if it has a finite cover by spectra of noetherian rings. f:X→Y is of finite type if Y is covered by Spec⁡Bi whose preimages are covered by finitely many Spec⁡Aij with each Aij a finitely generated Bi-algebra.
Fibre products and fibres. Fibre products exist, and Spec⁡A×Spec⁡RSpec⁡B=Spec⁡(A⊗RB). The fibre of f:X→Y over y is Xy=X×YSpec⁡κ(y), a scheme over κ(y) whose underlying space is f−1(y).
Separated and proper. f is separated if the diagonal X→X×YX is a closed immersion, and proper if it is separated, of finite type and universally closed. Affine morphisms are separated; projective morphisms of noetherian schemes are proper.
Valuative criteria. Let f be of finite type with X noetherian. For every valuation ring R with fraction field K, and every commuting square with Spec⁡K→X and Spec⁡R→Y: f is separated if and only if there is at most one lift Spec⁡R→X, and proper if and only if there is exactly one.

For a quadratic ring Z[x]/(x2−D), the fibre over (p) is Spec⁡(Z[x]/(x2−D)⊗Fp)=Spec⁡Fp[x]/(x2−D), so everything depends on how x2−D factors mod p.

Explore

The ring
Bottom row: Spec⁡Z. Top row: the points of the ring lying over each prime. Click a prime to select it. split, two points inert, one point ramified, one non-reduced point

Worked example

Let X=Spec⁡k[x,y,t]/(y2−x3−t) with the morphism f:X→A1=Spec⁡k[t], where k is algebraically closed of characteristic 0. Describe the fibres, including the generic fibre, and decide whether X itself is singular.

  1. Compute the fibre over the closed point t=c.

    k[x,y,t]/(y2−x3−t)⊗k[t]k[t]/(t−c)=k[x,y]/(y2−x3−c). The fibre is the affine plane curve y2=x3+c.

  2. Which closed fibres are singular?

    The partial derivatives −3x2 and 2y vanish together only at x=y=0, which lies on the curve only when c=0. So every fibre is nonsingular except the cusp y2=x3 over t=0.

  3. What is the generic fibre?

    Tensor with κ(η)=k(t): Xη=Spec⁡k(t)[x,y]/(y2−x3−t), a curve over the field k(t). It is nonsingular: a singular point would need x=y=0, and then t=0 in k(t), which is false.

  4. Is X itself singular?

    No. ∂/∂t of y2−x3−t is −1, never zero. In fact t=y2−x3, so X≅A2 with coordinates x,y. A nonsingular total space can have a singular fibre.

Check your understanding

What is the fibre of Spec⁡Z[i]→Spec⁡Z over (5)?

  1. One point, with residue field F25.Does x2+1 have a root mod 5? Try x=2.
  2. Two points, each with residue field F5.
  3. One non-reduced point.That happens only over 2, where x2+1=(x+1)2 mod 2.
x2+1≡(x−2)(x−3)(mod5), so F5[x]/(x2+1)≅F5×F5 by the Chinese remainder theorem.

How many points does Spec⁡C×Spec⁡RSpec⁡C have?

  1. One, since each factor has one point.The underlying set of a fibre product is not the fibre product of the sets. Compute C⊗RC.
  2. Two
  3. One non-reduced pointx2+1 has the distinct roots ±i in C.
C⊗RC≅C⊗RR[x]/(x2+1)≅C[x]/(x2+1)≅C×C, whose spectrum has two points.

Which of these morphisms to Spec⁡k is proper?

  1. A1→Spec⁡kIt is not universally closed: the projection A1×A1→A1 sends the closed set xy=1 onto A1∖{0}, which is not closed.
  2. P1→Spec⁡k
  3. The line with two origins →Spec⁡kIt is not separated: a map from the generic point of a DVR extends to its closed point in two ways, one through each origin.
Projective morphisms are proper. The other two each fail one half of the valuative criterion: existence for A1, uniqueness for the doubled line.

Practice

An arithmetic surfaceFibres of Spec ℤ[x]

Describe the fibres of Spec⁡Z[x]→Spec⁡Z over (p) and over (0). What is dim⁡Spec⁡Z[x]?

Solution

Over (p): Spec⁡Fp[x], the affine line over Fp. Over (0): Spec⁡Q[x]. So Spec⁡Z[x] is a family of lines over a one-dimensional base, and it has dimension 2. A maximal chain is (0)⊂(p)⊂(p,x).

Fibres that jumpA blow-up chart

Let f:A2→A2, (x,t)↦(x,tx). Describe the fibre over (a,b) when a≠0, when a=b=0, and when a=0≠b. Is the image closed?

Solution

For a≠0 the fibre is the single point (a,b/a). Over (0,0) it is the whole line x=0. Over (0,b) with b≠0 it is empty. The image is {x≠0}∪{(0,0)}, which is neither open nor closed (it is constructible). The dimension of the fibre jumps from 0 to 1 at the origin.

From Hartshorne, Algebraic Geometry (Springer GTM 52, 1977)

Numbers match the book. Each question is restated in our own words; the hints and solutions are written for this page.

Exercise II.3.10Fibres of a morphism

(a) Show the fibre Xy is homeomorphic to f−1(y). (b) For X=Speck[s,t]/(s−t2)→Y=Speck[s], with k algebraically closed, show: over s=a≠0 the fibre is two reduced points; over 0 it is a nonreduced point; over the generic point it is one point whose residue field has degree 2 over k(s).

Hint

Xy=X×YSpeck(y). Reduce to Y=SpecA, X=SpecB, and k(p)=Ap/pAp.

Solution

(a) Locally Xy=Spec(B⊗Ak(p)). Its primes correspond to primes of B lying over p (localise at p, then quotient by p), and localisation and quotient both induce homeomorphisms onto their images. These local homeomorphisms glue.

(b) B=k[t] with s=t2. Over s=a: k[t]/(t2−a)≅k×k if a≠0 (two points ±a), and k[t]/(t2) if a=0 (one point, nonreduced). Over the generic point: k(s)[t]/(t2−s), a field of degree 2 over k(s) (inseparable if char k=2).

Exercise II.4.12Valuation rings of function fields

Let k be algebraically closed. (a) For a function field K/k of dimension 1, show every valuation ring other than K is discrete, so they form the abstract curve CK. (b) For a surface X with function field K, show: (1) the local ring at the generic point of a curve Y⊂X is a DVR with centre that point; (2) if f:X′→X is birational and Y′⊂X′ is a curve mapping to a closed point x0, the local ring of Y′ is a DVR with centre x0; (3) for a sequence of blow-ups at points xi∈Ei over x0, with R0=⋃Oxi,Xi, any valuation ring R dominating R0 has centre x0. When is R a DVR?

Hint

(a) A valuation ring dominating a DVR with the same fraction field equals it. (b) A one-dimensional normal noetherian local domain is a DVR.

Solution

(a) Let R≠K be a valuation ring containing k. Pick x∈mR∖0. Then x is transcendental and K/k(x) is finite. The integral closure B of k[x] in K is a Dedekind domain contained in R (valuation rings are integrally closed), and mR∩B is a nonzero prime. So R dominates the DVR Bm∩B, and the two are equal since a DVR is a maximal subring for domination.

(b)(1) Ox1,X is a local domain of dimension 1, noetherian and integrally closed (X is nonsingular), hence a DVR. Its centre is x1.

(b)(2) The same argument on X′ shows the local ring R of Y′ is a DVR. f sends the generic point of Y′ to x0, giving a local homomorphism Ox0,X→R, so R dominates Ox0 and its centre is x0.

(b)(3) An increasing union of local rings with local inclusions is local, with maximal ideal ⋃mi. So R0 is local and dominated by some valuation ring R of K/k. Then R dominates Ox0,X, so its centre is x0.

Partial on the last question. Whether R is discrete depends on how the points are chosen. For example, if every xi+1 is the point where Ei+1 meets the strict transform of a fixed smooth curve C through x0, the resulting valuation measures order along C first and then order on C. Its value group is Z2 ordered lexicographically, so it is not discrete. I haven't written out the general criterion here; Zariski's work gives the full classification.

Worked exampleHartshorne, Ch. II §5: Sheaves of Modules · §6: Divisors · §7: Projective Morphisms · §8: Differentials

Line bundles, divisors and differentials

On Pn there is a line bundle O(d) for each integer d, and every line bundle is one of them. Divisors are the bookkeeping for line bundles, and differentials give every nonsingular variety a canonical one. This module is one long computation on two curves.

The idea

Quasi-coherent sheaves. On Spec⁡A, M↦M~ is an equivalence between A-modules and quasi-coherent O-modules. A sheaf of modules on a scheme is quasi-coherent if it is locally of this form, and coherent if locally M can be taken finitely generated (on a noetherian scheme).
Twisting sheaves. On Pn=Proj⁡k[x0,…,xn], O(d)=S(d)∼. Its global sections are the forms of degree d: Γ(Pn,O(d))=Sd, of dimension (n+dn) for d≥0 and 0 for d<0.
Weil divisors. On a noetherian integral separated scheme that is regular in codimension one, a divisor is a finite formal sum ∑niYi of prime divisors. A rational function has div⁡(f)=∑vY(f)Y, and Cl⁡X is divisors modulo these. Degree gives Cl⁡Pn≅Z.
Cartier divisors and Pic. Pic⁡X is the group of invertible sheaves up to isomorphism. If X is noetherian, integral, separated and locally factorial (for example nonsingular), then Cl⁡X≅Pic⁡X. So Pic⁡Pn≅Z, generated by O(1).
Differentials. For X nonsingular of dimension n over k, ΩX/k is locally free of rank n, and the canonical sheaf is ωX=∧nΩX/k. Then ωPn≅O(−n−1). Adjunction: a nonsingular hypersurface Y of degree d in Pn has ωY≅OY(d−n−1). For a curve, the genus is g=dim⁡Γ(X,ωX).

Worked example

On P1, with affine coordinate x and the point ∞ where u=1/x vanishes, and on the plane cubic C: y2=x3+1 with its point O=[0:1:0] at infinity: compute some divisors of functions and differentials, and read off Cl⁡P1, ωP1 and the genus of C. Work in characteristic 0.

  1. Compute div⁡(f) for f=x2/(x−1) on P1. Don't forget ∞.

    On A1: a double zero at 0 and a simple pole at 1. At ∞, with u=1/x: f=u−2u−1−1=1u(1−u), so ord∞⁡f=−1. Thus div⁡f=2[0]−[1]−[∞], of degree 0.

  2. Why does every principal divisor on P1 have degree 0, and why does that give Cl⁡P1≅Z?

    For f=p/q, the finite zeros and poles contribute deg⁡p−deg⁡q, and ord∞⁡f=deg⁡q−deg⁡p, so the total is 0. Conversely, a degree-0 divisor ∑ni[ai]+m[∞] (with m=−∑ni) is div⁡∏(x−ai)ni. So D∼(deg⁡D)[∞], and deg:Cl⁡P1→Z is an isomorphism.

  3. Compute the divisor of the differential dx on P1.

    At a finite point a, x−a is a local parameter and dx=d(x−a) has no zero or pole. At ∞, x=u−1, so dx=−u−2du, a pole of order 2. So K=div⁡(dx)=−2[∞], of degree −2, and ωP1≅O(−2), as the formula O(−n−1) says. Γ(ω)=0, so the genus is 0.

  4. On C, compute div⁡(x). The orders of x and y at O are −2 and −3.

    x=0 at (0,1) and (0,−1). There y≠0, so ∂f/∂y=2y≠0 and x is a local parameter: simple zeros. The only pole is at O, of order 2. So div⁡(x)=(0,1)+(0,−1)−2O. (The orders at O: x is a degree-2 map to P1 and O is its only point over ∞, and 2ord⁡y=3ord⁡x from the equation.)

  5. Show that ω=dx/y has no zeros or poles on C.

    Where y≠0, x minus a constant is a local parameter, so dx is a nonvanishing local generator and y is a unit. Where y=0 (the three points with x3=−1), differentiate the equation: 2ydy=3x2dx, so dx/y=2dy/(3x2), and 3x2≠0 there, while y is a local parameter. At O, with local parameter s: ord⁡(dx)=ord⁡(x)−1=−3 and ord⁡(y)=−3, so ord⁡(dx/y)=0. Hence KC=0, ωC≅OC, and g=dim⁡Γ(ωC)=dim⁡Γ(OC)=1.

  6. Check both answers with adjunction.

    A plane curve of degree d has ω≅O(d−3). For a conic, OC(−1), of degree −2, matching P1. For the cubic, OC(0)=OC, matching step 5. In general deg⁡K=d(d−3).

Check your understanding

What is dim⁡Γ(P2,O(3))?

  1. 10
  2. 9Count the monomials xaybzc with a+b+c=3 carefully.
  3. 4That is dim⁡Γ(P1,O(3)), the binary cubics.
Sections of O(3) are cubic forms in three variables, and there are (52)=10 monomials. This is why plane cubics form a P9.

On a nonsingular plane conic C≅P1, what is the degree of OC(1)?

  1. 1A line meets a conic in 2 points (Bézout).
  2. 2
  3. −2That is the degree of ωC≅OC(−1).
OC(1) is the divisor class of a line section, of degree 2. Under C≅P1 it is OP1(2): the conic is the image of P1 by quadrics.

Why is Cl⁡An=0?

  1. k[x1,…,xn] is a UFD, so every height-one prime is principal, and every prime divisor is div⁡(f).
  2. An has no prime divisors.It has plenty: every irreducible hypersurface.
  3. Every divisor on An is effective.−Z(x1) is not effective. The point is that it is principal: div⁡(1/x1).
A noetherian domain is a UFD exactly when its height-one primes are principal. If Y=Z(f) with f irreducible, then Y=div⁡(f).

Practice

The genus of a plane curveFrom the canonical degree

Use ωC≅OC(d−3) and deg⁡K=2g−2 to find the genus of a nonsingular plane curve of degree d.

Solution

deg⁡OC(1)=d (Bézout with a line), so deg⁡K=d(d−3). Then 2g−2=d2−3d gives g=(d−1)(d−2)2: 0, 0, 1, 3, 6 for d=1,…,5.

Sections of a divisor on ℙ¹Riemann–Roch's first case

For D=2[0]+[∞] on P1, find L(D)={f:div⁡f+D≥0}∪{0} and its dimension.

Solution

f may have a pole of order at most 2 at 0, at most 1 at ∞, and none elsewhere. So f=p(x)/x2 with p a polynomial, and ord∞⁡f=2−deg⁡p≥−1 forces deg⁡p≤3. So L(D)={(a+bx+cx2+dx3)/x2}, of dimension 4=deg⁡D+1, matching O(3).

From Hartshorne, Algebraic Geometry (Springer GTM 52, 1977)

Numbers match the book. Each question is restated in our own words; the hints and solutions are written for this page.

Exercise II.6.1Class groups of products with projective space

Let X be noetherian, integral, separated and regular in codimension one. Show X×Pn has the same properties and Cl(X×Pn)≅ClX×Z.

Hint

Use Cl(X×An)≅ClX, and the exact sequence for removing the closed subset X×H, with H a hyperplane.

Solution

The product properties are standard: X×Pn is covered by X×An's, it is integral, separated over X, and its codimension-1 local rings are regular because the fibres are smooth.

There is an exact sequence Z→Cl(X×Pn)→Cl(X×An)→0, where 1↦[X×H], and by iterating the A1 case, Cl(X×An)≅ClX via p∗. Define ClX×Z→Cl(X×Pn) by (D,m)↦p∗D+m[X×H].

Onto: a class restricts on X×An to p∗D, so it differs from p∗D by a multiple of X×H.

One-to-one: if p∗D+m[X×H]=(f), restrict to the generic fibre PK(X)n. There p∗D restricts to 0, and X×H restricts to a hyperplane of degree 1, so m=deg⁡(f)=0. Then p∗D is principal, so its restriction to X×An is principal, and D=0 in ClX.

Exercise II.8.4Complete intersections in Pn

Y⊂Pn is a complete intersection if IY is generated by r=codimY forms. (a) Show this holds iff Y=H1∩⋯∩Hr scheme-theoretically for hypersurfaces Hi. (b) If dim⁡Y≥1 and Y is normal, show Y is projectively normal. (c) Deduce Γ(Pn,O(l))→Γ(Y,OY(l)) is onto for l≥0, and Y is connected. (d) Use Bertini to find nonsingular Hi of degrees di (r<n) whose intersection is irreducible, nonsingular and of codimension r. (e) For such Y, show ωY≅OY(∑di−n−1). (f) For a nonsingular hypersurface of degree d, show pg=(d−1n)=pa. (g) For a nonsingular complete intersection curve of surfaces of degrees d,e in P3, show pg=12de(d+e−4)+1.

Hint

The homogeneous coordinate ring S/(f1,…,fr) is a complete intersection ring, hence Cohen–Macaulay. For normality use Serre's criterion. For (e), I/I2≅⨁OY(−di).

Solution

(a) If IY=(f1,…,fr), take Hi=V(fi). Conversely, scheme-theoretic intersection means the ideal sheaves add, so IY is generated by the local equations of the Hi.

(b) The affine cone C(Y)=SpecS/(fi) is Cohen–Macaulay, so it satisfies S2. Away from the vertex it is locally Y×A1∖0, which is normal. The vertex has codimension dim⁡Y+1≥2, so R1 holds. Serre's criterion makes S(Y) normal, i.e. Y is projectively normal.

(c) For projectively normal Y the map in question is onto in every degree (Ex. 5.14). With l=0, Γ(OY)=k, so Y is connected.

(d) Induct. Take H1 nonsingular (e.g. Fermat). Given a nonsingular irreducible complete intersection Yi of codimension i<n−1, embed Pn by the di+1-uple embedding. Bertini then gives a hypersurface Hi+1 of degree di+1, itself nonsingular (an open condition), with Yi∩Hi+1 nonsingular of codimension i+1. It is connected by (c), hence irreducible.

(e) By adjunction for a local complete intersection, ωY≅ωPn⊗det(I/I2)∨|Y=OY(−n−1+∑di).

(f) ωY=OY(d−n−1). From 0→O(−n−1)→O(d−n−1)→OY(d−n−1)→0 and H0,H1 of O(−n−1) vanishing, pg=h0(OPn(d−n−1))=(d−1n). This equals pa by I, Ex. 7.2.

(g) ωY=OY(d+e−4), and the Koszul complex together with (c) gives pg=(d+e−13)−(e−13)−(d−13), which simplifies to 12de(d+e−4)+1. (Checks: (2,2) gives 1; (2,3) gives 4.)

InteractiveHartshorne, Ch. III §4: Čech Cohomology · §5: The Cohomology of Projective Space · §7: The Serre Duality Theorem

Cohomology of projective space

The cohomology of O(d) on Pn can be computed by hand with the Čech complex of the standard affine cover, and the answer is a count of monomials. Slide d and watch H0 and Hn trade places.

The idea

Sheaf cohomology. Hi(X,−) are the right derived functors of Γ(X,−) on sheaves of abelian groups. A short exact sequence of sheaves gives a long exact sequence in cohomology. On a noetherian space of dimension n, Hi=0 for i>n.
Affine schemes have no higher cohomology. If X is a noetherian affine scheme, Hi(X,F)=0 for all i>0 and all quasi-coherent F. Consequently, on a noetherian separated scheme, Čech cohomology for any open affine cover computes Hi.
Line bundles on Pn. Use the cover Ui={xi≠0}. Then H0(O(d))=Sd; Hi(O(d))=0 for 0<i<n; and Hn(O(d)) has a basis of Laurent monomials x0a0⋯xnan with every ai≤−1 and ∑ai=d. In particular hn(O(d))=h0(O(−d−n−1)).
Serre duality. For X projective and nonsingular of dimension n over k, and F locally free: Hi(X,F)≅Hn−i(X,F∨⊗ωX)∨. On Pn, with ω=O(−n−1), this is the symmetry above.

Why monomials: on Ui0∩⋯∩Uip the sections of O(d) are spanned by Laurent monomials of degree d whose negative exponents occur only among xi0,…,xip. A monomial with some exponent ≥0 is already a section on a smaller intersection and dies in Hn; a monomial with all exponents ≥0 is a global section.

Explore

Each dot is a Laurent monomial of degree d, placed by its exponents of x0 (across) and x1 (up). basis of H0 basis of Hn
Projective space

Worked example

Let C⊂P2 be a curve defined by an irreducible form of degree d. Compute h0(OC) and h1(OC).

  1. Write down a short exact sequence relating OC to sheaves on P2.

    The ideal sheaf of C is generated by its equation f, of degree d, so it is isomorphic to O(−d):

    0→OP2(−d)→ ⋅f OP2→OC→0.
  2. Take the long exact sequence. What is h0(OC)?

    0→H0(O(−d))→H0(O)→H0(OC)→H1(O(−d)). The outer terms are 0 (no forms of negative degree; no intermediate cohomology) and H0(O)=k. So h0(OC)=1.

  3. Now h1(OC).

    0=H1(O)→H1(OC)→H2(O(−d))→H2(O)=0, so h1(OC)=h2(O(−d)).

  4. Count the monomials.

    We need a,b,c≤−1 with a+b+c=−d. Put a=−1−a′ and so on: a′+b′+c′=d−3 with a′,b′,c′≥0. There are (d−12)=(d−1)(d−2)2 solutions. Set d=3 in the explorer on P2 with twist −3: exactly one monomial, x0−1x1−1x2−1, so a plane cubic has h1(OC)=1.

Check your understanding

What is h1(P2,O(d))?

  1. 0, for every d
  2. h0(O(−d−3))On a surface, Serre duality pairs H1 with H1: h1(O(d))=h1(O(−d−3)). That relation doesn't decide the value.
  3. Nonzero when d<0Only H0 and Hn of a line bundle on Pn can be nonzero.
The intermediate cohomology of every O(d) on Pn vanishes. In the monomial picture, any degree-d Laurent monomial either has all exponents ≥0, all ≤−1, or is killed in the Čech complex.

What is h2(P2,O(−5))?

  1. 6
  2. 3Count solutions of a+b+c=−5 with every exponent ≤−1: substitute a=−1−a′, etc.
  3. 0H2(O(d)) vanishes only for d≥−2.
a′+b′+c′=2 has (42)=6 solutions, and Serre duality agrees: h0(O(5−3))=h0(O(2))=6. Check it in the explorer.

Why does the vanishing of higher cohomology on affine schemes matter for Pn?

  1. It lets the Čech complex of the cover {Ui} compute Hi(Pn,F).
  2. It shows H1(Pn,F)=0 for every sheaf.Pn is not affine: H1(P1,O(−2)) is one-dimensional.
  3. It shows every sheaf on Pn is quasi-coherent.That is a different question, and false.
If every finite intersection of the cover is affine (which holds on a separated scheme) and the sheaf has no higher cohomology there, the Čech complex is acyclic enough to compute derived functor cohomology.

Practice

H¹ of ℙ¹ from scratchThe Čech complex by hand

Using the cover U0,U1 of P1, compute H1(P1,O(−2)) directly from the Čech complex.

Solution

Degree −2 Laurent monomials x0ax1b, a+b=−2. Sections on U0 allow a<0 but need b≥0; on U1, a≥0; on U0∩U1 anything. H1 is the cokernel of Γ(U0)⊕Γ(U1)→Γ(U01), spanned by the monomials with both a,b≤−1. With a+b=−2 there is only x0−1x1−1. So h1=1, matching h0(O(0))=1 by duality.

Euler characteristic on ℙ³A polynomial in d

Check that χ(P3,O(d))=(d+33)=(d+1)(d+2)(d+3)6 also for d=−4 and d=−5, by counting monomials.

Solution

For d≤−1 only H3 survives, and χ=−h3. For d=−4: all four exponents −1, one monomial, χ=−1, and the formula gives (−3)(−2)(−1)/6=−1. For d=−5: one exponent is −2, four monomials, χ=−4, and the formula gives (−4)(−3)(−2)/6=−4.

From Hartshorne, Algebraic Geometry (Springer GTM 52, 1977)

Numbers match the book. Each question is restated in our own words; the hints and solutions are written for this page.

Exercise III.5.1Euler characteristic is additive

For coherent sheaves on a projective scheme over k, define χ(F)=∑(−1)idim⁡Hi(X,F). Show χ(F)=χ(F′)+χ(F″) for a short exact sequence 0→F′→F→F″→0.

Hint

The long exact cohomology sequence is a finite exact sequence of finite-dimensional vector spaces.

Solution

The cohomology groups are finite-dimensional and vanish above dim⁡X, so the long exact sequence is a finite exact sequence of finite-dimensional spaces. In such a sequence the alternating sum of dimensions is 0 (split it into short exact sequences). Grouping the terms by sheaf gives χ(F′)−χ(F)+χ(F″)=0.

Exercise III.5.3Arithmetic genus, cohomologically

Define pa(X)=(−1)r(χ(OX)−1) for X projective of dimension r. (a) If X is integral and k algebraically closed, show H0(OX)=k and pa=∑i=0r−1(−1)idim⁡Hr−i(OX); for a curve, pa=h1(OX). (b) Show this agrees with the Hilbert polynomial definition for X⊂Pn. (c) For nonsingular projective curves, show pa is a birational invariant, and deduce that a nonsingular plane curve of degree d≥3 is not rational.

Hint

H0(OX) is a finite-dimensional k-algebra that is a domain. For (b), the Hilbert polynomial is n↦χ(OX(n)) (Ex. 5.2).

Solution

(a) H0(OX) is a finite-dimensional domain over k, hence a finite field extension, hence k. So χ(OX)−1=∑i≥1(−1)ihi. Multiplying by (−1)r and reindexing gives the formula, which for r=1 is h1.

(b) PX(n)=χ(OX(n)) for all n, so PX(0)=χ(OX) and the two definitions agree.

(c) Birational nonsingular projective curves are isomorphic, so h1(OX) is a birational invariant. A plane curve of degree d≥3 has pa=12(d−1)(d−2)≥1, whereas pa(P1)=0.

Exercise III.5.5Cohomology of complete intersections

Let Y⊂X=Pkn be a complete intersection of dimension q≥1. Show: (a) H0(X,OX(l))→H0(Y,OY(l)) is onto for all l; (b) Y is connected; (c) Hi(Y,OY(l))=0 for 0<i<q and all l; (d) pa(Y)=dim⁡Hq(Y,OY).

Hint

Induct on the codimension, using 0→OY′(l−d)→OY′(l)→OY(l)→0, where Y=Y′∩H and H has degree d.

Solution

The base case Y=X is the cohomology of Pn: Hi(O(l))=0 for 0<i<n. Write Y=Y′∩V(f), where Y′ is a complete intersection of dimension q+1 and f has degree d. Since the generators form a regular sequence, f is a nonzerodivisor on OY′, so the sequence in the hint is exact.

(c) Hi(OY(l)) sits between Hi(OY′(l)) and Hi+1(OY′(l−d)), and both vanish for 0<i<q, since then i+1<q+1.

(a) H0(OY′(l))→H0(OY(l)) is onto because H1(OY′(l−d))=0 (using q+1≥2). Compose with the surjection for Y′, which holds by induction.

(b) By (a) with l=0, H0(OY) is the image of k, so equals k. Hence Y is connected.

(d) χ(OY)=1+(−1)qhq, so pa=(−1)q(χ−1)=hq.

InteractiveHartshorne, Ch. IV §1: Riemann–Roch Theorem · §3: Embeddings in Projective Space · §5: The Canonical Embedding

The Riemann–Roch theorem

How many functions on a curve have poles only at one point P, of order at most n? Riemann–Roch answers up to a correction term, and the correction disappears once n is large. The pole orders that cannot occur are the Weierstrass gaps, and there are always exactly g of them.

The idea

Here a curve is a complete nonsingular curve over an algebraically closed field k.

Linear systems. For a divisor D, L(D)={f∈K∗:div⁡f+D≥0}∪{0}≅H0(X,O(D)), and l(D)=dim⁡L(D). The genus is g=l(K)=h1(OX).
Riemann–Roch.  l(D)−l(K−D)=deg⁡D+1−g.
Consequences. deg⁡K=2g−2. If deg⁡D>2g−2 then l(K−D)=0 and l(D)=deg⁡D+1−g. If deg⁡D≥2g, |D| has no base points; if deg⁡D≥2g+1, D is very ample. For g≥2 the canonical map is an embedding exactly when X is not hyperelliptic.
Weierstrass gaps. n≥1 is a gap at P if l(nP)=l((n−1)P), that is, no function has a pole of order exactly n at P and no other poles. Since l goes up by at most 1 per step, l(0)=1 and l((2g−1)P)=g, there are exactly g gaps, all in [1,2g−1].

Explore

Curve and point P
l(nP) n+1−g the correction l(K−nP) gaps

Worked example

Let X be the genus-2 curve y2=h(x), with h of degree 5 with distinct roots, and let P be its single point at infinity. Find L(nP) explicitly and check Riemann–Roch. (Characteristic 0.)

  1. What are the pole orders of x and y at P?

    x:X→P1 has degree 2, and P is the only point over ∞, so ordP⁡x=−2. From y2=h(x): 2ordP⁡y=5ordP⁡x=−10, so ordP⁡y=−5. Both are regular on the affine part.

  2. Find l(4P) and check it against Riemann–Roch.

    Functions regular away from P are polynomials in x,y, and using y2=h(x) every such function is a(x)+b(x)y. Poles: a(x) has even order 2deg⁡a, and b(x)y has odd order 2deg⁡b+5, so no cancellation is possible. For n=4: 1,x,x2, so l(4P)=3. Riemann–Roch: deg⁡(K−4P)=2−4<0, so l(4P)=4+1−2=3.

  3. Use n=2 to find the canonical class.

    L(2P)=⟨1,x⟩, so l(2P)=2. Riemann–Roch: 2−l(K−2P)=2+1−2, so l(K−2P)=1. Since deg⁡K=2, K−2P has degree 0 and a section, so K∼2P. Indeed dx/y has divisor exactly 2P: at P, ord⁡(dx)−ord⁡(y)=−3+5=2, and it has no zeros or poles elsewhere.

  4. What are the gaps at P?

    The pole orders that occur are 0,2,4,5,6,7,… (even numbers from xk, and 2k+5 from xky). So the gaps are 1 and 3: two of them, as g=2 requires. Choose "Genus 2, Weierstrass point" in the explorer.

Check your understanding

X has genus 3 and D has degree 7. What is l(D)?

  1. 5
  2. 8That is deg⁡D+1, the answer on P1. Riemann–Roch subtracts g.
  3. It depends on D.Once deg⁡D>2g−2, deg⁡(K−D)<0, so l(K−D)=0 and l(D) is determined.
7>2g−2=4, so l(D)=7+1−3=5.

On an elliptic curve, is there a function with a single simple pole and no other poles?

  1. No.
  2. Yes: x in a Weierstrass equation.x has a double pole at O.
  3. Yes: Riemann–Roch gives l(P)=2.It gives l(P)−l(K−P)=1+1−1=1, and l(K−P)=l(−P)=0, so l(P)=1.
l(P)=1: only the constants. A function with one simple pole would be a degree-1 map X→P1, hence an isomorphism, but g=1≠0.

How many Weierstrass gaps does a point on a curve of genus 4 have?

  1. 4
  2. 7The gaps lie in [1,7], but only g of those numbers are gaps.
  3. None, for a general point.Every point has exactly g gaps. At a general point they are 1,…,g.
l(nP) climbs from l(0)=1 to l(7P)=7+1−4=4 in 7 steps of size 0 or 1, so 3 steps go up and 4 are gaps.

Practice

Degree 0 and degree 2 on an elliptic curveWhere the correction term lives

On an elliptic curve X, find l(D) for every divisor of degree 0, and for every divisor of degree 2.

Solution

Degree 0: if f∈L(D) is nonzero, div⁡f+D is effective of degree 0, hence 0, so D∼0. So l(D)=1 if D∼0 and 0 otherwise. Degree 2: 2>2g−2=0, so l(D)=2+1−1=2. The correction term l(K−D)=l(−D) is nonzero only in degree 0, and only for D∼0.

Reading off the correctionGenus 4

On a curve of genus 4, a divisor D of degree 5 has l(D)=3. Find l(K−D), and show that K∼D+Q for some point Q.

Solution

3−l(K−D)=5+1−4=2, so l(K−D)=1. deg⁡(K−D)=6−5=1, and a nonzero f∈L(K−D) makes div⁡f+K−D an effective divisor of degree 1, a single point Q. So K∼D+Q.

From Hartshorne, Algebraic Geometry (Springer GTM 52, 1977)

Numbers match the book. Each question is restated in our own words; the hints and solutions are written for this page.

Exercise IV.1.5dim⁡|D|≤deg⁡D

For an effective divisor D on a curve X of genus g, show dim⁡|D|≤deg⁡D, with equality iff D=0 or g=0.

Hint

l(D−P)≥l(D)−1. Equality all the way down produces a point P with l(P)=2.

Solution

Induct on d=deg⁡D; d=0 gives l(0)=1. For D=D′+P, vanishing at P is one linear condition, so l(D′)≥l(D)−1, and hence l(D)≤l(D′)+1≤d+1.

If l(D)=d+1 with d≥1, the chain of inequalities forces l(D′)=d at every step, down to a single point P with l(P)=2. A nonconstant function with only a simple pole at P gives a morphism X→P1 of degree 1, so X≅P1 and g=0. Conversely, on P1, l(D)=d+1.

Exercise IV.1.7Hyperelliptic curves

X is hyperelliptic if g≥2 and there is a degree-2 map X→P1. (a) If g=2, show |K| has degree 2, dimension 1 and no base points, so X is hyperelliptic. (b) Show the curves of (1.1.1) (curves of type (2,g+1) on a quadric surface) all have degree-2 maps to P1, so hyperelliptic curves exist in every genus g≥2.

Hint

deg⁡K=2g−2 and l(K)=g. A base point P would force l(P)=2.

Solution

(a) deg⁡K=2, l(K)=2. If P were a base point, then l(K−P)=2. Riemann–Roch gives l(K−P)−l(P)=deg⁡(K−P)+1−g=0, so l(P)=2, forcing g=0 by Exercise 1.5. So |K| is base-point-free of degree 2 and defines a degree-2 morphism to P1.

(b) A curve of type (2,g+1) on Q≅P1×P1 meets each fibre of one projection in 2 points, so that projection restricts to a degree-2 map to P1. Its genus is (2−1)(g+1−1)=g by III, Ex. 5.6.

InteractiveHartshorne, Ch. IV §2: Hurwitz's Theorem

Hurwitz's formula

A finite map of curves relates their genera through how much it ramifies. When the target is P1, computing a genus turns into counting branch points.

The idea

Degree and ramification. A finite morphism of curves f:X→Y has degree n=[K(X):K(Y)]. For P↦Q, with t a local parameter at Q, the ramification index is eP=vP(f∗t). Over each Q, ∑P↦QeP=n. P is a ramification point if eP>1, and then Q is a branch point.
Hurwitz. If f is separable, then 2g(X)−2=n(2g(Y)−2)+deg⁡R. When all ramification is tame (char⁡k=0, or the characteristic divides no eP), deg⁡R=∑P(eP−1).
Two quick consequences. A separable map P1→P1 of degree n has ∑(eP−1)=2n−2. And there is no nonconstant separable map from a curve to one of larger genus, since the right side would exceed the left.

Explore

The map
The sheets of X over the base P1. Over an ordinary point there are n points; at a branch point, sheets merge into one point with ramification index e. branch points

Worked example

Find the genus of the nonsingular projective model of y3=x4−1 (characteristic 0), using the map (x,y)↦x.

  1. What is the degree of the map?

    For a general value of x, the equation y3=x4−1 has three distinct solutions y. So the degree is 3.

  2. Where is it ramified over finite values of x?

    Over x=ζ with ζ4=1, the only point is (ζ,0). There x4−1=(x−ζ)u with u a unit, so y is a local parameter and x−ζ=y3u−1 vanishes to order 3: e=3. Over every other finite x there are three points, so no ramification.

  3. What happens over x=∞?

    Homogenise: Y3Z=X4−Z4. At Z=0 this forces X=0, so the curve has a single point [0:1:0] at infinity, and it is the only point over x=∞. Hence e=3 there too.

  4. Apply Hurwitz, and check the answer another way.

    Five ramification points with e=3: 2g−2=3⋅(−2)+5⋅2=4, so g=3. Check: F=X4−Z4−Y3Z has partials 4X3, −3Y2Z, −4Z3−Y3, which vanish together only at X=Y=Z=0. So the closure is a nonsingular plane quartic, and g=3⋅22=3.

Check your understanding

X has genus 4 and f:X→P1 has degree 2. How many branch points are there (characteristic 0)?

  1. 10
  2. 8Solve 2g−2=2(−2)+B with g=4.
  3. 9For a double cover the number is 2g+2, always even.
Each branch point of a double cover has one point above it with e=2, contributing 1. So 6=−4+B, B=10=2g+2.

Is there a nonconstant morphism P1→E to an elliptic curve?

  1. No.
  2. Yes, of degree 2.Degree-2 maps go the other way, E→P1.
  3. Only in positive characteristic.Hurwitz needs separability, but a purely inseparable map preserves the genus, so no characteristic allows it.
For a separable map, Hurwitz would give −2=n⋅0+deg⁡R≥0, which is impossible.

For a separable map P1→P1 of degree n, what is ∑P(eP−1) (tame case)?

  1. 2n−2
  2. n−1That is the contribution of one totally ramified point. z↦zn has two of them.
  3. 0That would need −2=−2n, so only n=1.
−2=n(−2)+∑(eP−1). Choose "z ↦ zⁿ" in the explorer: two points with e=n.

Practice

A cyclic coverRamification at infinity too

Find the genus of the nonsingular projective model of y5=x(x−1), using the map to the x-line (characteristic 0).

Hint

For yn=h(x) with n prime (characteristic 0), the points over x=a are totally ramified when n does not divide the order of h at a, and unramified when it does. At ∞ that order is −deg⁡h.

Solution

Degree 5. Over 0 and 1, h has order 1, and over ∞ order −2; 5 divides none of these, so each of the three is totally ramified, with e=5. Hurwitz: 2g−2=5(−2)+3⋅4=2, so g=2.

Genus 2 over an elliptic curveCounting ramification points

Suppose a curve X of genus 2 has a degree-2 map onto an elliptic curve E (characteristic 0). How many ramification points does it have?

Solution

2⋅2−2=2(2⋅1−2)+∑(eP−1), so ∑(eP−1)=2. For a double cover each ramification point has e=2, so there are exactly 2.

From Hartshorne, Algebraic Geometry (Springer GTM 52, 1977)

Numbers match the book. Each question is restated in our own words; the hints and solutions are written for this page.

Exercise IV.2.2Curves of genus 2

Let char k≠2. (a) For X of genus 2, show the canonical map f:X→P1 is ramified at exactly 6 points, each with index 2; f, and so the 6 branch points up to AutP1, is determined by X. (b) Conversely, for distinct α1,…,α6, show z2=∏(x−αi) defines a curve of genus 2 whose canonical map is x, branched exactly over the αi. (c) Show AutP1 acts simply transitively on ordered triples, so we may take the branch points to be 0,1,∞,β1,β2,β3. (d)–(e) Conclude that genus 2 curves correspond to triples {βi} modulo an action of Σ6.

Hint

Hurwitz: 2g−2=n(2⋅0−2)+deg⁡R. With tame ramification and degree 2, each ramification point contributes 1.

Solution

(a) 2=2(−2)+deg⁡R, so deg⁡R=6. Since eP≤2 and the ramification is tame, each ramification point has eP=2 and contributes 1, giving exactly 6 points. Any isomorphism of genus 2 curves carries |K| to |K|, so the branch set is determined up to AutP1.

(b) K=k(x,z) has degree 2 over k(x). Ramification occurs exactly where ∏(x−αi) has odd valuation: at the αi, but not at ∞, where the valuation is −6, even. Hurwitz gives 2g−2=−4+6, so g=2. For genus 2, any g21 is |K|: Riemann–Roch gives l(K−D)=1 with deg⁡(K−D)=0, so D∼K. Hence x is the canonical map.

(c) z↦(z−P1)(P2−P3)(z−P3)(P2−P1) sends P1,P2,P3 to 0,1,∞. Uniqueness: a Möbius map fixing three points is the identity.

(d)–(e) Reordering the six branch points by σ∈Σ6 and renormalising the first three to 0,1,∞ defines the action. By (a)–(c), isomorphism classes of genus 2 curves correspond to 6-element subsets of P1 modulo AutP1, i.e. to triples (β1,β2,β3) of distinct elements ≠0,1 modulo Σ6: a 3-parameter family.

InteractiveHartshorne, Ch. IV §3: Embeddings in Projective Space · §4: Elliptic Curves

Elliptic curves and the group law

A curve of genus 1 with a chosen point is a group. On a plane cubic the group law is a ruler construction: draw the line through P and Q, take the third point where it meets the curve, and reflect.

The idea

Elliptic curve. A curve X of genus 1 with a point P0. Since 3≥2g+1, the divisor 3P0 is very ample, and l(3P0)=3: it embeds X in P2 as a cubic. If char⁡k≠2,3, coordinates can be chosen so that the cubic is y2=x3+ax+b with 4a3+27b2≠0, and P0=[0:1:0], a flex whose tangent line is the line at infinity.
The group. P↦O(P−P0) is a bijection from X(k) to Pic0⁡X, and the group structure is carried over from Pic0: P+Q=R exactly when P+Q∼R+P0 as divisors. On the cubic, P+Q+R=0 exactly when P,Q,R are the three intersections of a line with X, counted with multiplicity.
The j-invariant. j=1728⋅4a34a3+27b2. Two elliptic curves over k are isomorphic exactly when they have the same j, and every j∈k occurs.

The formulas behind the explorer: for P=(x1,y1), Q=(x2,y2) with x1≠x2, the slope is λ=(y2−y1)/(x2−x1), or λ=(3x12+a)/(2y1) for P=Q. Then x3=λ2−x1−x2 and P+Q=(x3, λ(x1−x3)−y1).

Explore

Drag P and Q along the curve. line through P and Q third point R P + Q, the reflection of R

Worked example

On E:y2=x3+1 over Q, with O=[0:1:0], find the order of the point P=(2,3).

  1. Compute 2P with the tangent line.

    λ=3⋅4+02⋅3=2, so x3=4−2−2=0 and y=2(2−0)−3=1. So 2P=(0,1).

  2. Compute 3P=(0,1)+(2,3).

    λ=3−12−0=1, x3=1−0−2=−1, y=1⋅(0−(−1))−1=0. So 3P=(−1,0).

  3. What is the order of P?

    (−1,0) has y=0, so it equals its own negative (x,−y): 2⋅3P=O. Neither 2P nor 3P is O, so P has order 6.

  4. So (0,1)=2P has order 3. What does that say about the tangent line at (0,1)?

    3⋅(0,1)=0 means the tangent line at (0,1) meets E only there, with multiplicity 3: it is a flex. Directly, the slope there is 3x2/(2y)=0, and the line y=1 gives x3=0, a triple root. Since a=0, j=0.

Check your understanding

On y2=x3+ax+b, what is −P for P=(x,y)?

  1. (x,−y)
  2. (−x,−y)The curve is symmetric under y↦−y, not under (x,y)↦(−x,−y). That point is usually not even on the curve.
  3. The third point on the tangent line at PThat point is −2P.
The vertical line through P meets the curve at P, (x,−y) and O. Collinear points sum to 0, so P+(x,−y)=0. Use "Set Q = −P" in the explorer.

Over C, how many points P satisfy 2P=0?

  1. 4
  2. 3Don't forget the identity O.
  3. 22P=0 means the tangent at P passes through O, i.e. is vertical: that happens where y=0.
O and the three points (ei,0), where ei are the roots of x3+ax+b. Together they form Z/2×Z/2.

Why is P↦O(P−P0) injective?

  1. If P∼Q with P≠Q, a function with divisor P−Q would give a degree-1 map X→P1, forcing g=0.
  2. Because Pic0⁡X is torsion-free.It isn't: the previous question found points of order 2.
  3. Because l(P)=2.On a genus-1 curve l(P)=1.
O(P−P0)≅O(Q−P0) means P∼Q. A nonconstant f with div⁡f=P−Q has a single simple pole, so it is an isomorphism onto P1, which is impossible for g=1.

Practice

Two j-invariantsNot isomorphic

Compute j for y2=x3−x and y2=x3+1. Are these curves isomorphic over C?

Solution

y2=x3−x: a=−1, b=0, so 4a3=−4 and j=1728. y2=x3+1: a=0, so j=0. Different j, so not isomorphic. These are the two curves with extra automorphisms: (x,y)↦(−x,iy) on the first, (x,y)↦(ωx,y) on the second.

Why collinear points add to zeroA line is a divisor of degree 3

If a line L meets the cubic in P,Q,R, show that P+Q+R=0 in the group law defined through Pic0.

Solution

Let L also denote a linear form defining the line, and Z the line at infinity, which meets the cubic in 3P0. The rational function L/Z has divisor P+Q+R−3P0. So (P−P0)+(Q−P0)+(R−P0)∼0, which is P+Q+R=0.

From Hartshorne, Algebraic Geometry (Springer GTM 52, 1977)

Numbers match the book. Each question is restated in our own words; the hints and solutions are written for this page.

Exercise IV.4.1The graded ring of an elliptic curve

For an elliptic curve X (char ≠2) and P∈X, show that R=⨁n≥0H0(OX(nP)) is isomorphic, as a graded ring, to k[t,x,y]/(y2−x(x−t2)(x−λt2)), with deg⁡t=1, deg⁡x=2, deg⁡y=3.

Hint

l(nP)=n for n≥1. Count monomials in each degree.

Solution

Let t∈R1 be the constant 1 (in degree 1), x∈R2 a function with a double pole at P, and y∈R3 one with a triple pole. In degree 6 there are seven monomials y2,x3,t2x2,t4x,t6,txy,t3y in a space of dimension 6, so there is a relation. Both y2 and x3 must appear in it (they are the only ones with a pole of order 6). Completing the square (char ≠2) and moving the roots of the cubic to 0 and t2 by affine changes in x gives y2=x(x−t2)(x−λt2).

So there is a graded homomorphism k[t,x,y]/(F)→R. In degree n≥1, the monomials taxbyc with c≤1 and a+2b+3c=n number exactly n and have distinct pole orders 2b+3c at P, so they form a basis of Rn. Hence the map is an isomorphism.

Exercise IV.4.4j of a general Weierstrass equation

For y2+a1xy+a3y=x3+a2x2+a4x+a6, show j is a rational function of the ai with rational coefficients, so j∈k0 if all ai∈k0. Conversely, show that for every α∈k0 there is an elliptic curve defined over k0 with j=α.

Hint

Use the standard quantities b2,b4,b6,b8,c4,Δ, with j=c43/Δ. For the converse, write down one family.

Solution

With b2=a12+4a2, b4=2a4+a1a3, b6=a32+4a6, b8=a12a6+4a2a6−a1a3a4+a2a32−a42, c4=b22−24b4 and Δ=−b22b8−8b43−27b62+9b2b4b6, we have j=c43/Δ: a polynomial expression in the ai with integer coefficients, divided by Δ≠0. In characteristic ≠2,3 this reduces to the book's j=1728⋅4a3/(4a3+27b2) after completing the square and cube.

For the converse: for α≠0,1728, the curve y2+xy=x3−36α−1728x−1α−1728 has j=α. For α=0, use y2+y=x3; for α=1728, use y2=x3+x (in characteristics 2 and 3, where 1728=0, the first two cases suffice). All are defined over k0.

InteractiveHartshorne, Ch. V §1: Geometry on a Surface · §2: Ruled Surfaces

Intersection numbers on a surface

On a surface, two curves meet in finitely many points, and the count depends only on their divisor classes. On the quadric P1×P1 every class is a pair of numbers, and the count is a one-line formula you can check by drawing.

The idea

A surface here is a nonsingular projective surface over an algebraically closed field.

Intersection pairing. There is a unique symmetric bilinear pairing Pic⁡X×Pic⁡X→Z, (C,D)↦C⋅D, such that C⋅D=#(C∩D) when C,D are nonsingular curves meeting transversally. For curves with no common component, C⋅D=∑Pdimk⁡OP/(f,g).
Adjunction and Riemann–Roch. For a curve C on X: 2pa(C)−2=C⋅(C+K), and pa is the genus if C is nonsingular. For a divisor D: l(D)−s(D)+l(K−D)=12D⋅(D−K)+1+pa(X), where s(D)=h1(O(D)).
Hodge index theorem. If H is ample, D⋅H=0 and D is not numerically equivalent to 0, then D2<0.
The quadric and ruled surfaces. X=P1×P1 is the quadric surface in P3. Pic⁡X=ZV⊕ZH, where V is a "vertical" fibre {pt}×P1 and H a "horizontal" one, with V2=H2=0, V⋅H=1 and K=−2V−2H. A class C=aV+bH is cut out by a form of bidegree (a,b). More generally a ruled surface π:X→C has Pic⁡X≅ZC0⊕π∗Pic⁡C for a section C0 with C02=−e.

Then (aV+bH)⋅(cV+dH)=ad+bc and pa(aV+bH)=(a−1)(b−1). The explorer represents aV+bH by a vertical and b horizontal lines; any other curve in the class gives the same numbers.

Explore

P1×P1. C=aV+bH D=cV+dH points of C∩D

Worked example

Let φ:P1→P1 be a morphism of degree n, and Γ⊂P1×P1 its graph {(x,φ(x))}. Find the class of Γ, check adjunction, and count fixed points.

  1. Write Γ=aV+bH. Compute Γ⋅V and Γ⋅H.

    A vertical line {x0}×P1 meets Γ once, at (x0,φ(x0)), so Γ⋅V=b=1. A horizontal line P1×{y0} meets it at the n preimages of y0, so Γ⋅H=a=n. Thus Γ=nV+H.

  2. Compute Γ2 and check the genus by adjunction.

    Γ2=2n. And Γ⋅(Γ+K)=2n+(nV+H)⋅(−2V−2H)=2n−2n−2=−2, so pa(Γ)=0, as it must be: Γ≅P1.

  3. Fixed points of φ are the points of Γ∩Δ, where Δ=V+H is the diagonal. How many are there, counted with multiplicity?

    Γ⋅Δ=(nV+H)⋅(V+H)=n+1. Example: φ(z)=z2 fixes 0, 1 and ∞, which is 3=2+1.

  4. Check the Hodge index theorem on D=V−H, with the ample class V+H.

    D⋅(V+H)=1−1=0 and D is not numerically trivial (D⋅V=−1). Indeed D2=−2<0.

Check your understanding

In how many points do general curves in the classes 2V+H and V+3H on P1×P1 meet?

  1. 7
  2. 5Vertical meets horizontal, never vertical. Pair the 2 verticals of one with the 3 horizontals of the other, and so on.
  3. 6You counted only one of the two cross terms ad and bc.
(2V+H)⋅(V+3H)=2⋅3+1⋅1=7. Set a=2,b=1,c=1,d=3 in the explorer and count the red dots.

A nonsingular curve in the class 3V+3H has genus:

  1. 4
  2. 1That is a plane cubic. On the quadric use adjunction with K=−2V−2H.
  3. 18That is C2=2⋅3⋅3, not the genus.
pa=(a−1)(b−1)=4. Such a curve is the intersection of the quadric with a cubic surface in P3, a canonical curve of genus 4.

Can an irreducible curve on P1×P1 have negative self-intersection?

  1. No: its class is aV+bH with a,b≥0, so C2=2ab≥0.
  2. Yes, the diagonal.Δ=V+H has Δ2=2.
  3. Yes, after moving it.C2 depends only on the class, and moving doesn't change the class.
a=C⋅H and b=C⋅V, and an irreducible curve meets a fibre that is not one of its components in an effective way, so both are ≥0. Contrast the exceptional curve of a blow-up, with E2=−1 (next module).

Practice

Genus-1 curves on the quadricWhich classes, and which degree?

Which classes aV+bH with a,b≥1 contain curves of arithmetic genus 1? Embedding the quadric in P3 by V+H, what is the degree of such a curve?

Solution

(a−1)(b−1)=1 forces a=b=2. The degree is the intersection with a hyperplane section: (2V+2H)⋅(V+H)=4. These are the elliptic quartic curves, intersections of the quadric with a second quadric.

The ruled surface X₁ℙ² blown up at a point

Let X be P2 blown up at a point p, with L the pullback of a line and E the exceptional curve (L2=1, L⋅E=0, E2=−1, K=−3L+E). Show that the lines through p become the fibres of a ruling over P1 with E as a section, and find e.

Solution

Their strict transforms have class F=L−E, with F2=1−1=0: disjoint, the fibres of projection from p. E⋅F=0−(−1)=1, so E meets each fibre once and is a section with E2=−1, so e=1. Adjunction checks: F⋅(F+K)=0+(L−E)⋅(−3L+E)=−3+1=−2 and E⋅(E+K)=−1−1=−2, so both are rational curves. Also K2=9−1=8, the same as for P1×P1.

From Hartshorne, Algebraic Geometry (Springer GTM 52, 1977)

Numbers match the book. Each question is restated in our own words; the hints and solutions are written for this page.

Exercise V.1.3Arithmetic genus of curves on a surface

With pa(D)=1−χ(OD): (a) for an effective divisor D on a surface X, show 2pa−2=D.(D+K); (b) show pa(D) depends only on the linear equivalence class of D; (c) defining pa for any D by the same formula, show pa(−D)=D2−pa(D)+2 and pa(C+D)=pa(C)+pa(D)+C.D−1.

Hint

0→O(−D)→OX→OD→0 and Riemann–Roch χ(L(E))=12E.(E−K)+χ(OX).

Solution

(a) χ(OD)=χ(OX)−χ(O(−D))=−12(−D).(−D−K)=−12D.(D+K), so 2pa−2=−2χ(OD)=D.(D+K).

(b) Intersection numbers depend only on linear equivalence classes.

(c) 2pa(−D)−2=(−D).(K−D)=D2−D.K=2D2−D.(D+K)=2D2−(2pa(D)−2). Also (C+D).(C+D+K)=C.(C+K)+D.(D+K)+2C.D. Rearrange both.

Exercise V.1.5Computing K2

(a) If X is a surface of degree d in P3, show K2=d(d−4)2. (b) If X=C×C′ with genera g,g′, show K2=8(g−1)(g′−1).

Hint

(a) Adjunction: ωX=OX(d−4). (b) KX=p1∗KC+p2∗KC′, and p1∗A.p2∗B=deg⁡Adeg⁡B, (p1∗A)2=0.

Solution

(a) K=(d−4)H and H2=d, so K2=(d−4)2d.

(b) K2=2deg⁡KCdeg⁡KC′=2(2g−2)(2g′−2)=8(g−1)(g′−1).

Exercise III.5.6Curves on a nonsingular quadric

On Q={xy=zw}≅P1×P1⊂P3, write OQ(a,b) for the sheaf of a divisor of type (a,b). (a) Show: (1) if |a−b|≤1 then H1(OQ(a,b))=0; (2) if a,b<0 then H1=0; (3) if a≤−2 then H1(OQ(a,0))≠0. (b) Show: (1) a locally principal subscheme of type (a,b) with a,b>0 is connected; (2) for a,b>0 there is an irreducible nonsingular curve of type (a,b); (3) such a curve is projectively normal iff |a−b|≤1. (c) Show pa(Y)=ab−a−b+1 for type (a,b).

Hint

OQ(a,b)=p1∗O(a)⊗p2∗O(b), and the Künneth formula gives H1=H0(O(a))⊗H1(O(b))⊕H1(O(a))⊗H0(O(b)). (The book suggests computing with disjoint unions of lines; Künneth reaches the same conclusions.) Then use 0→OQ(−a,−b)→OQ→OY→0.

Solution

(a) On P1, H0(O(m))≠0 iff m≥0, and H1(O(m))≠0 iff m≤−2. So H1(OQ(a,b))≠0 iff one of a,b is ≥0 and the other is ≤−2. This forces |a−b|≥2, which gives (1). (2): both H0 factors vanish. (3): H1(O(a))⊗H0(O)≠0.

(b)(1) The sequence gives H0(OQ)=k→H0(OY)→H1(OQ(−a,−b))=0 by (a)(2). So H0(OY)=k and Y is connected.

(b)(2) For a,b>0, |OQ(a,b)| is very ample (the Segre embedding composed with a Veronese). Bertini gives a nonsingular member, which is connected by (1), hence irreducible.

(b)(3) H0(P3,O(n))→H0(OQ(n,n)) is onto (a quadric is projectively normal), and H0(OQ(n,n))→H0(OY(n))→H1(OQ(n−a,n−b))→H1(OQ(n,n))=0. So restriction is onto for all n iff H1(OQ(n−a,n−b))=0 for all n, iff |a−b|≤1 (if, say, a≥b+2, take n=b). For integral normal Y, surjectivity in all degrees is projective normality. The simplest non-example, type (1,3), is the rational quartic curve.

(c) Künneth makes χ multiplicative: χ(OQ(−a,−b))=(1−a)(1−b). So χ(OY)=1−(1−a)(1−b) and pa=1−χ(OY)=(a−1)(b−1)=ab−a−b+1.

InteractiveHartshorne, Ch. V §3: Monoidal Transformations · §4: The Cubic Surface in ℙ³

Blowing up and the 27 lines

Blow up six points of the plane in general position and map the result to P3 by the cubics through them: the image is a nonsingular cubic surface. Its 27 lines can be listed from the six points, and intersection numbers say which lines meet.

The idea

Blowing up a point. Let π:X~→X be the blow-up of a point P on a surface, with exceptional curve E≅P1. Then Pic⁡X~≅Pic⁡X⊕ZE, with π∗C⋅π∗D=C⋅D, π∗C⋅E=0, E2=−1, and KX~=π∗KX+E.
Strict transforms. If C has multiplicity r at P, then π∗C=C~+rE, C~⋅E=r, and pa(C~)=pa(C)−r(r−1)2.
The cubic surface. Let X be P2 blown up at six points with no three on a line and not all six on a conic. Cubics through the six points form a 4-dimensional space of sections, and they embed X in P3 as a nonsingular cubic surface with hyperplane class −K=3L−∑Ei. Every nonsingular cubic surface arises this way.
The 27 lines. A line on X is a curve ℓ with ℓ2=−1 and K⋅ℓ=−1. There are exactly 27: the six Ei; the fifteen Lij=L−Ei−Ej (lines through two of the points); the six Cj=2L−∑i≠jEi (conics through five of them). With D=aL−∑biEi, the pairing is D⋅D′=aa′−∑bibi′.

Explore

Drag the six points. Click a point, line or conic (or a button) to pick one of the 27 lines. selected the 10 lines meeting it
Pick a line

Worked example

Let C⊂P2 be a cubic with a node at P, and blow up P. Find the class of C~, its self-intersection, its genus and how it meets E.

  1. Write π∗C in terms of C~ and E, and find the class of C~.

    A node has multiplicity 2, so π∗C=C~+2E and C~=3L−2E, where L is the pullback of a line.

  2. Compute C~⋅E. What does it mean?

    (3L−2E)⋅E=0−2E2=2. The strict transform meets E in two points, one for each tangent direction at the node, which is what the animation in the rational maps module shows.

  3. Compute C~2 and the genus of C~ by adjunction, with K=−3L+E.

    C~2=9−4=5. Since C~+K=(3L−2E)+(−3L+E)=−E, we get C~⋅(C~+K)=(3L−2E)⋅(−E)=−3L⋅E+2E2=0−2=−2. So pa(C~)=0, matching pa(C)−2⋅12=1−1.

  4. What changes if P is a cusp instead?

    All the numbers stay the same, since a cusp also has multiplicity 2. But the two intersection points of C~ and E coincide: C~ is tangent to E at the single tangent direction.

Check your understanding

On a nonsingular cubic surface, how many of the other 26 lines meet a given line?

  1. 10
  2. 26Lines on a surface can be disjoint: E1⋅E2=0.
  3. 16That is the number of lines disjoint from it.
For E1: the five L1j and the five conics Cj, j≠1, each with intersection number 1. Every line looks the same (the symmetry group of the configuration acts transitively), and the explorer counts 10 for any choice.

Blow up P2 at a point. The strict transform of a line through the point has self-intersection:

  1. 0
  2. 1That is L2 before blowing up. The class is now L−E.
  3. −1That is E2, or (L−Ei−Ej)2 for a line through two blown-up points.
(L−E)2=L2−2L⋅E+E2=1−0−1=0.

If three of the six points are collinear, the strict transform of their line has class L−E1−E2−E3. What is its self-intersection, and what goes wrong?

  1. −2, and K⋅ℓ=0: the cubics contract this curve to a point, a singular point of the image surface.
  2. −1: it is just another line.Each blown-up point on the line lowers the self-intersection by 1.
  3. 0: it moves in a family.Compute 1−3.
ℓ2=1−3=−2, and −K⋅ℓ=3−3=0, so the hyperplane class has degree 0 on ℓ: the map to P3 collapses it. Drag three points into a line in the explorer to see the warning.

Practice

The degree of the cubic surfaceK² and lines

For X=P2 blown up at six points, show K2=3, and that each Ei has degree 1 in the embedding by −K.

Solution

K=−3L+∑Ei, so K2=9+∑Ei2=9−6=3: the surface has degree (−K)2=3. And −K⋅Ei=(3L−∑Ej)⋅Ei=−Ei2=1, so Ei maps to a curve of degree 1, a line.

Two skew lines and their transversalsCounting with classes

E1 and E2 are disjoint. How many of the 27 lines meet both?

Solution

Lines meeting E1: L1j (j≠1) and Cj (j≠1). Lines meeting E2: L2j and Cj (j≠2). Both: L12 and C3,…,C6. That is 5. Pick E1 and then E2 in the explorer to see them.

From Hartshorne, Algebraic Geometry (Springer GTM 52, 1977)

Numbers match the book. Each question is restated in our own words; the hints and solutions are written for this page.

Exercise V.3.2Intersections after blowing up

Let C,D be curves on a surface meeting at P, and π:X~→X the blow-up at P. Show C~.D~=C.D−μP(C)μP(D). Conclude that C.D=∑μP(C)μP(D) over all intersection points, including infinitely near ones.

Hint

π∗C=C~+μP(C)E, π∗C.E=0 and E2=−1.

Solution

With r=μP(C) and s=μP(D),

C~.D~=(π∗C−rE).(π∗D−sE)=C.D−0−0+rsE2=C.D−rs.

Repeat at each intersection point of the strict transforms. After finitely many blow-ups the strict transforms no longer meet over P: the local intersection number is finite and drops by at least 1 each time. Summing the drops gives C.D=∑μ(C)μ(D) over all actual and infinitely near intersection points.

Exercise V.4.16The 27 lines on the Fermat cubic

For the Fermat cubic x03+x13+x23+x33=0 (char ≠3), find the 27 lines explicitly, verify their incidences, and find the automorphism group.

Hint

Pair up the coordinates: xi3+xj3=0 factors into linear forms.

Solution

Lines. For each of the 3 ways to split {0,1,2,3} into pairs {i,j},{k,l}, and each pair of cube roots of unity ω,ω′, the line xi=−ωxj, xk=−ω′xl lies on the surface. That gives 3×3×3=27 distinct lines.

Incidences. Two lines with the same pairing meet iff they share ω or share ω′: if they share ω, both lie in the plane xi=−ωxj and meet where xk=xl=0. That gives 4 lines. For lines with different pairings, say x0=−ax1, x2=−bx3 and x0=−cx2, x1=−dx3, setting x3=1 shows they meet iff ad=bc. That gives 3 lines from each of the 2 other pairings, so 6. Each line meets 4+6=10 others, as on any smooth cubic surface.

Automorphisms. Multiplying coordinates by cube roots of unity (modulo overall scalars) gives (Z/3)3, and permuting coordinates gives S4. Together they form (Z/3)3⋊S4 of order 648. This is the full automorphism group over an algebraically closed field of characteristic 0 (the linear automorphisms of a cubic surface preserving the equation). I haven't proved here that there are no others; that is the standard result for the Fermat cubic.